Why Short Sellers Help Keep The Stock Market In Check: 'Pricing Mechanism Is Broken' Without Them

A stock buying frenzy by online groups of retail traders, led by Reddit’s WallStreetBets community, has triggered massive short squeezes in highly shorted stocks like GameStop Corp. GME, AMC Entertainment Holdings Inc AMC and others in recent weeks.

Many onlookers, such as influential Tesla Inc TSLA CEO Elon Musk, have praised the efforts to bring down institutional short sellers, while others have rushed in to defend short sellers as an important part of a healthy market.

“U can’t sell houses u don’t own, u can’t sell cars u don’t own but u *can* sell stock u don’t own!? This is bs – shorting is a scam legal only for vestigial reasons,” Musk said in a tweet last week.

Musk Calls Out Shorts: Musk has long been critical of short sellers, and has often publicly taunted David Einhorn and other Tesla shorts. Tesla is by far the most heavily shorted stock in the world, according to S3 Partners.

“Here come the shorty apologists...give them no respect...get Shorty,” Musk said.

On a recent edition of Benzinga's PreMarket Prep, co-host Dennis Dick took a few minutes to defend the role short sellers play in price discovery in a free market.

“Shorts are the pricing mechanism. It’s what keeps prices in line. It’s what provides liquidity to the market. Without shorts, you have no liquidity. Without shorts, you have stocks go up like GameStop,” Dick said.

Related Link: WallStreetBets Posters Warn Retail Traders On Silver Squeeze: 'The Antithesis Of Who We Are'

Recipe For Bubbles: Dick said removing short sellers from the market plants seeds for extreme market bubbles and elevated risk for investors.

“A lot of people get hurt in the end of this. We don’t know when the party ends, but it always does. So without shorts to keep prices in check, the pricing mechanism is broken,” Dick said.

Dick pointed out that regulators banned short selling on financial stocks for three weeks during the 2008 financial crisis, and the results weren't good.

“In those three weeks, the overall stock market fell 18%. Guess what the financials did? They fell 23%...All it did was increase volatility, and they fell more than then overall market.”

Carson Block's Take: Short seller Carson Block of Muddy Waters Research also stepped up to defend short sellers in an interview with Bloomberg TV this week.

"I believe at the end of the day, that the research that we produce has utility. It has led to eight delistings…and a case against tariff evasion," Block said.

Block said short sellers along with market regulators help sniff out fraud and deception in financial markets.

"Does research like this matter? Yeah, I think it does. From a social utility perspective, yes. But there's less social utility to it when the SEC isn't enforcing as heavily as it used to. So I like to think that under the new administration there's more social utility...kind of a counterweight to the extreme dishonestly that's surged through the market the past several years."

Benzinga's Take: Musk and other CEOs of public companies understandably dislike anyone who believes their companies' share prices are too high. However, the best defense against short sellers is a successful business, as Tesla has demonstrated in recent years.

Posted In: Carson BlockDennis DickElon MuskMuddy WatersMuddy Waters ResearchPreMarket PrepAnalyst ColorShort SellersPsychologyTop StoriesAnalyst RatingsTrading IdeasGeneral

Ad Disclosure: The rate information is obtained by Bankrate from the listed institutions. Bankrate cannot guaranty the accuracy or availability of any rates shown above. Institutions may have different rates on their own websites than those posted on Bankrate.com. The listings that appear on this page are from companies from which this website receives compensation, which may impact how, where, and in what order products appear. This table does not include all companies or all available products.

All rates are subject to change without notice and may vary depending on location. These quotes are from banks, thrifts, and credit unions, some of whom have paid for a link to their own Web site where you can find additional information. Those with a paid link are our Advertisers. Those without a paid link are listings we obtain to improve the consumer shopping experience and are not Advertisers. To receive the Bankrate.com rate from an Advertiser, please identify yourself as a Bankrate customer. Bank and thrift deposits are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. Credit union deposits are insured by the National Credit Union Administration.

Consumer Satisfaction: Bankrate attempts to verify the accuracy and availability of its Advertisers' terms through its quality assurance process and requires Advertisers to agree to our Terms and Conditions and to adhere to our Quality Control Program. If you believe that you have received an inaccurate quote or are otherwise not satisfied with the services provided to you by the institution you choose, please click here.

Rate collection and criteria: Click here for more information on rate collection and criteria.