Toy Stories Turn As Hasbro Vanquishes Bigger Brother Mattel

The first-quarter results of the two largest publicly traded U.S. toymakersHasbro, Inc. HAS and Mattel, Inc. MAT — are already out, and in biblical proportions, Davidian Hasbro rose in stature and ranks to topple the Mattel Goliath.

Q1 Summary

Mattel reported last Thursday a first-quarter adjusted loss per share of $0.32, wider than the loss of $0.14 a year earlier. Net sales were down 15 percent to $735.6 million.

Analysts, on average, estimated a loss of $0.17 per share on revenues of $801 million.

The company blamed the shortfall on retail inventory overhang coming out of the holiday period.

Margo Georgiadis, CEO of Mattel, commented:

    "We are confident we have worked through the majority of this overhang and look forward to a strong launch of Walt Disney Co (NYSE: )'s 'Cars 3' theatrical release in the second quarter. While we have a lot of work to do to successfully position Mattel for the future, we see a clear runway to improving growth and profitability over time."

Georgiadis, a former Google executive, took the reins of the company on February 8, the second change to the CEO position since 2015.

Meanwhile, Hasbro, which released its first-quarter results on Monday, said its first-quarter revenues rose 2 percent to $849.7 million. Net earnings increased to $0.54 per share from the year-ago's $0.38 per share.

The results trumped the consensus estimates that called for earnings of $0.32 per share on revenues of $822.1 million. The icing on the cake was Hasbro's revenue dollars surpassing that of Mattel for the first time since 2000.

HAS Revenue (Quarterly) Chart Source: Y Charts

Mattel's Brand Weakness

  • Barbie: Down 16 percent.
  • Other Girls Brands: Down 34 percent (the loss of Disney Princess doll license business, beginning in 2016, is still hurting the company).
  • Wheels Category: Up 4 percent.
  • Entertainment Business: Down 27 percent.
  • Fisher-Price Brands: Down 9 percent.
  • American Girl Brands: Down 12 percent.
  • Construction And Arts & Crafts Brands: Down 38 percent.

Hasbro's Gaming: Competitive Differentiator

  • Hasbro said in its earnings release that Hasbro total gaming revenue, including all gaming revenue, mainly Magic: The Gathering and Monopoly, came in at $253.3 million, up 10 percent.
  • Franchise brand revenues rose 2 percent to $423.6 million, helped by revenue growth in Nerf, Transformers and Monopoly. Hasbro gaming revenues climbed 43 percent to $142.9 million.
  • Emerging brand revenue rose 25 percent to $70.2 million.
  • However, partner brand revenue fell 18 percent to $213 million.

Stocks Reflect Divergence In Fundamentals

Ever since Hasbro and Mattel reported their fourth-quarter results in late January, the stocks have taken a divergent route. As opposed to the 30 percent gains for Hasbro, Mattel's shares have slid 20.9 percent in the year-to-date period.

MAT Chart Source: Y Charts

Analysts Bank On Mattel's Turnaround

Unlike naïve investors, analysts have placed bets on the struggling Mattel. A Barron's report, quoting Wells Fargo analyst Timothy Conder, said he prefers Mattel over Hasbro, as Mattel is still in the early innings of its turnaround, leaving a long runway for growth ahead.

The analyst also sees a number of catalyst for Mattel in the year ahead, including clearance of channel inventory, "Cars 3" success and working capital improvement progress, etc.

Hasbro's stock, which shot to an all-time closing high of $101.70 on Monday, by virtue of a 6 percent rally, was last seen losing 0.58 percent to $101.11. On the other hand, Mattel's stock, which pulled back about 13 percent last Friday, was advancing 1.62 percent to $21.95.

Related Links:

Hasbro Vs. Mattel: Which Was The Better Toy Story In 2016?

Benzinga's Bulls And Bears Of The Week: Facebook, Goldman Sachs, EBay And More

Market News and Data brought to you by Benzinga APIs
Comments
Loading...
Date
ticker
name
Actual EPS
EPS Surprise
Actual Rev
Rev Surprise
Posted In: Analyst ColorEarningsNewsGuidanceAnalyst RatingsMoversMargo Georgiadis
Benzinga simplifies the market for smarter investing

Trade confidently with insights and alerts from analyst ratings, free reports and breaking news that affects the stocks you care about.

Join Now: Free!