Skip to main content

Market Overview

Why China Just Caused Wall Street's Biggest Solar Bear To Change His Mind

Why China Just Caused Wall Street's Biggest Solar Bear To Change His Mind

One of Wall Street's biggest solar stock bears suddenly changed his tune Thursday.

Axiom Capital Managing Director Gordon Johnson upgraded the entire alternative energy sector from Market Underweight to Market Overweight and upgraded SolarCity Corp (NASDAQ: SCTY) from Sell to Hold and Trina Solar Limited (ADR) (NYSE: TSL), Yingli Green Energy Holding Co Ltd (ADR) (NYSE: YGE) and JA Solar Holdings Co., Ltd. (ADR) (NASDAQ: JASO) from Sell to Buy.

Johnson came on Benzinga's PreMarket Prep morning show to explain why he suddenly sees upside in an industry he's been bearish on since 2006.

Related Link: Gordon Johnson And Solar Stocks: A Chronology Of Bearishness

Feed-In Tariffs

As outlined in his note, the Chinese government unexpectedly announced last week that it would cut its Feed-in Tariff (FiT) in the middle of next year by 27 percent. Johnson explained the impact like this:

"Solar power is more expensive than traditional fossil fuels. So, what governments do to incentivize people to implement and use solar power is they provide you a Feed-in Tariff, which is essentially a payment that exceeds the cost of solar. So, if you install it, you get a payment in excess of what it costs to install — making it economically beneficial to you.

"The way to think about that is if you’re going to install a panel before a Feed-in Tariff cut, that system is a 20-year system that gets that same Feed-in Tariff for the next 20 years. So, if you were thinking of doing a solar project in 2018–2019 and you know there's a 27 percent average cut coming in China July 1, 2017, you're probably going to rush all of a sudden to get that done in the first half of 2017 so you can lock in that 20 year FiT before it gets cut."

Johnson explained how Spain experienced the same phenomenon in 2008. That year, they saw about a 400 percent increase in solar demand because of a cut to the Feed-in Tariff.

"The reason that is, is because in 2008 the government signaled in 2009 they were going to cap the amount of solar they were subsidizing," Johnson said. "So, all of a sudden you had people rushing to get projects done to lock in those great incentives before they got cut."

He continued, "The way to think about this, is solar is very economical, particularly in places with beneficial Feed-in Tariffs, because the government is essentially paying you to do it. So, when governments [cut the FiT] it always creates demand pull-in. Given China is the biggest solar market in the world and they're basically giving you a nine-month lead time to rush and get your utility system done, we think you’re going to have the demand pull-in of all demand pull-ins in that market — which is going to push prices higher we think."

Where Johnson Sees Value

Trina Solar is rumored to be going private at $11.60, but that didn't stop Johnson from giving the stock a $15 price target. 

"The point is, if industry fundamentals turn and stocks start to move higher, and Trina sees that its stock is being weighed down by this go-private offer, we think they’ll pull the go-private offer. In fact, we don't know how real it is in the first place," Johnson said.

He said the same thing goes for SolarCity, currently in the midst of a controversial merger with Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ: TSLA). He explained it as follows:

    "The reason why we’ve upgraded SolarCity to hold is No. 1, we initiated a Sell in the $40s; No 2., typically when solar stocks move higher, which we think they are, other stocks follow suit. Even though, anecdotally, higher module prices [are] actually quite negative for the rooftop boys.
    "[W]e think solar stocks moving higher in general will push other solar stocks higher. Essentially, we’re taking our ball home. We’re calling it quits on the short. We think you want to be long these things. All these stocks have underperformed the market to some degree. We think that given the underperformance of these stocks, investors are going to revisit these things, particularly the clean energy funds out there, and that could provide some significant multiple expansion for these stocks."

Short-Term Opportunity

However, Johnson reiterated his long-term thesis on the industry, saying that these changes present a short-term opportunity for investors. "I just want to make it clear, our long-term subdued outlook on solar technology and stocks remains firmly entrenched. However, what we see here is a three- to six-month opportunity."

Johnson continued, "There were a couple of times that we've upgraded the stocks due to exactly this [...] but in general, we've been bearish solar stocks all along. And we maintain our bearish long-term view." 

At Last Check ...

  • JA Solar was up 4.32 percent at $6.88.
  • SolarCity was down 2.64 percent at $19.51.
  • ADRs of Trina Solar were up 1.22 percent at $10.39.
  • Yinglin was up 4.11 percent at $4.05.

Listen to the full discussion at 9:06 in the clip below. 

PreMarket Prep is a daily trading ideas show that focuses on technical analysis and actionable short term trades. You can listen to the show live every morning from 8-9 ET here, or catch the podcast here

Full ratings data available on Benzinga Pro.

Do you have ideas for articles/interviews you'd like to see more of on Benzinga? Please email with your best article ideas. One person will be randomly selected to win a $20 Amazon gift card!

Latest Ratings for JASO

Aug 2017Credit SuisseMaintainsNeutral
Aug 2017Axiom CapitalDowngradesHoldSell
Jul 2017Axiom CapitalUpgradesSellHold

View More Analyst Ratings for JASO
View the Latest Analyst Ratings


Related Articles (JASO + SCTY)

View Comments and Join the Discussion!

Posted-In: Analyst Color Long Ideas News Upgrades Commodities Top Stories Exclusives Markets Best of Benzinga

Don't Miss Any Updates!
News Directly in Your Inbox
Subscribe to:
Benzinga Premarket Activity
Get pre-market outlook, mid-day update and after-market roundup emails in your inbox.
Market in 5 Minutes
Everything you need to know about the market - quick & easy.
Fintech Focus
A daily collection of all things fintech, interesting developments and market updates.
Everything you need to know about the latest SPAC news.
Thank You

Thank you for subscribing! If you have any questions feel free to call us at 1-877-440-ZING or email us at