Skip to main content

Market Overview

Are Changes Coming To The P2P Lending Model?

Are Changes Coming To The P2P Lending Model?

  • Shares of LendingClub Corp (NYSE: LC) have lost nearly 50 percent year-to-date.
  • The company's CEO continues to maintain a view that its peer-to-peer lending structure hasn't been impacted by the Madden v. Midland case.
  • Michael Tarkan of Compass Point Research maintained a Sell rating and $12 price target on the stock as investors are "avoiding" peer-to-peer loans due to regulatory and legal risk.
  • LendingClub was the first peer-to-peer lender to file for an IPO and raised $900 million in 2014 – marking the largest U.S. tech IPO of the year. The company's peer-to-peer model introduces loan seekers to individual investors who offer loans at a typically higher interest rates versus what banks and other traditional lending institutions offer.

    In a report published Monday, Michael Tarkan of Compass Point maintained a Sell rating on LendingClub with a $12 price target as investor appetite is "evolving" to account for the Madden v. Midland case.

    "The Madden v. Midland case, which called into question federal preemption laws for non-bank institutions in NY, CT, and VT, has reportedly been driving changes in investor demand for marketplace loans originated in those three states," Tarkan explained.

    Related Link: Rightscorp Renews Representation Agreement For Peer-To-Peer Data Monitoring

    "Specifically, marketplace lender Avant, as well as Bank of New York Mellon and Prospect Capital, have reportedly considered pulling loans within securitization pools to avoid interest rate usury issues. Goldman Sachs, Credit Suisse, and JP Morgan have also reportedly contemplated limiting exposure to loans originated in those states. And rating agencies Moody's and Fitch have recently cautioned investors over the same topic."

    LendingClub's Management's Take

    However, LendingClub's management continues to state that its operations has seen "essentially no impact" following the Madden ruling in states where it operates. Management also noted that it is "having no trouble" funding loans in New York, Connecticut and Vermont and that it continues to see "plenty of investor interest."

    Impact On Retail

    With that said, Tarkan questioned where this leaves the retail investors. The analyst suggested that if what the company's management has said is true, retail investors "may be at a disadvantage" relative to institutional investors.

    In fact, demand from the "more sophisticated institutional segment" has evolved to the point where some investors are completely avoiding these loans to avoid any potential "unforeseeable issues."

    Tarkan continued that firms like LendingClub are evaluating changes to their business structure to avoid any Madden-related issues. However, if LendingClub were to institute state interest rate caps, it could drive lower volume, lead to increased credit, interest rate risk for investors and elevated funding risk for the company.

    Looking Ahead

    While Tarkan acknowledged that the Madden case does not "force" the company to alter its current loan issuance model, recent instances of institutional investors avoiding loans within the Madden-related states "serves as a signal" that changes to the current framework are ahead. As such, near-term disruption and/or weaker loan-level economics "will be inevitable."

    Image Credit: Public Domain


    Related Articles (LC)

    View Comments and Join the Discussion!

    Posted-In: Avant Bank of New York Mellon Compass Point Research Credit Suisse Goldman SachsAnalyst Color Analyst Ratings Tech Best of Benzinga

    Latest Ratings

    ETCredit SuisseMaintains13.0
    IFRXCredit SuisseMaintains2.8
    METCredit SuisseMaintains68.0
    FLXNCredit SuisseMaintains14.0
    ENPHCapital OneInitiates Coverage On175.0
    View the Latest Analytics Ratings
    Don't Miss Any Updates!
    News Directly in Your Inbox
    Subscribe to:
    Benzinga Premarket Activity
    Get pre-market outlook, mid-day update and after-market roundup emails in your inbox.
    Market in 5 Minutes
    Everything you need to know about the market - quick & easy.
    Fintech Focus
    A daily collection of all things fintech, interesting developments and market updates.
    Everything you need to know about the latest SPAC news.
    Thank You

    Thank you for subscribing! If you have any questions feel free to call us at 1-877-440-ZING or email us at