Market Overview

Bluegrass Capital's Apple Short Via Twitter Exceeds 160 Characters

Bluegrass Capital's Apple Short Via Twitter Exceeds 160 Characters

Securities analyst Bluegrass Capital posted a fairly in-depth short thesis on Apple Inc (NASDAQ: AAPL) Tuesday via Twitter.

(Click to enlarge)

The post makes a number of compelling points that could lead to further declines in the name, which has lost more than 20 percent over the last 52 weeks.

To support its short position, Bluegrass identified six key areas where the company has weaknesses. These include leadership, capital allocation, over-dependence on one product, the declining relevance of the smartphone, Apple's closed ecosystem and the company's scale.

Related Link: Could Facebook Be Berkshire's Next Tech Buy?

The first weak point that the author identifies is Apple's current leadership in the wake of Steve Job's death. The analyst wrote that Jobs "has been dead now for several years, and never created a sustainable culture that will allow the company to continue to create and develop new products/services that consumers desire." This has been an ongoing debate in the investment community for quite a while.

The key question becomes: Can Apple continue to innovate in the absence of its visionary founder? So far, the company has not excelled in this area, although the jury is still out.

In another section of the document, Bluegrass pointed out that Apple is earning 90 percent of the profits in the smartphone market with just 20 percent of the total installed base, meaning that the company has eye-popping margins. The analyst wrote, "The company is dramatically over earning vs its peer group, and economic theory + mean reversion would make the case that this dominance will not continue indefinitely."

In the piece, Bluegrass also touches on scale, noting that in order to move the needle on the share price, Apple will "need to develop new products/services w/ correspondingly huge market opportunities."

The problem currently, according to Bluegrass Capital, is that "in every current identifiable large consumer or technology vertical (outside of smartphones), AAPL has no existing, competitive offering, while all of its peers have successful products growing rapidly."

Full ratings data available on Benzinga Pro.

Do you have ideas for articles/interviews you'd like to see more of on Benzinga? Please email with your best article ideas. One person will be randomly selected to win a $20 Amazon gift card!

Posted-In: Bluegrass CapitalShort Ideas Tech Trading Ideas Best of Benzinga


Related Articles (AAPL)

View Comments and Join the Discussion!

Twitter Shares Have Historically Dropped 9% The Day After Earnings

Stock Index Futures Steady Ahead of FOMC