UNITE HERE: Brookfield Asset Management's Offer to Buyout Brookfield Property Partners Is Less Than What Brookfield Has Said the Assets Are Worth

Loading...
Loading...

UNITE HERE, the hospitality union, has released a report questioning the price of Brookfield Asset Management's BAM offer to buy out public investors of Brookfield Property Partners' BPY at $16.50 per unit. The report analyzes pre- and post-pandemic statements by BPY and BAM consistently arguing that BPY is undervalued in the public markets and concludes that those statements point to a price between $19.50-$21.00 per unit.

In the third quarter of 2020, BAM's Chief Executive Officer Bruce Flatt noted that "[BPY's] current trading price does not reflect anywhere near the value of the high-quality portfolio of real estate that it owns."

Meanwhile, in late September 2020, Bryan Davis, BPY's Chief Financial Officer stated: "And that investment today can be made at a substantial discount to intrinsic value, 60% if you consider it relative to our IFRS value, or 50% if you consider it relative to consensus NAV."

The report presents these and other Brookfield-related quotes and substantiation for the following key points. It can be found here: https://www.pecloserlook.org/bpy/

  • In the third quarter of 2020, BAM reported the value of "non-controlling interests" in BPY at $26 billion, while its buyout offer is valued at $5.9 billion;
  • BAM and BPY executives publicly stated in 2019 and 2020 that BPY's trading prices undervalued its assets;
  • At Brookfield's Investor Day presentation in September 2020, management reported BPY's net asset value (NAV) at $27.01 and stated the consensus NAV of analysts was $19.50 per unit;
  • The premium to BPY's unaffected trading price offered by BAM in this deal is 14%, lower than the premium Brookfield companies have offered in a sampling of buyouts over the last several years.
  • BAM has amassed $75 billion of capital and dry powder to invest in distressed assets and the post-pandemic economy.

"Brookfield Property investors have financed a world-class portfolio, which BPY's and BAM's executives have in the past year valued higher than $16.50, the price offered in this related-party buyout," says Dana Wise, research deputy director for UNITE HERE.

Loading...
Loading...
Market News and Data brought to you by Benzinga APIs
Posted In: Press Releases
Benzinga simplifies the market for smarter investing

Trade confidently with insights and alerts from analyst ratings, free reports and breaking news that affects the stocks you care about.

Join Now: Free!

Loading...