Skip to main content

Market Overview

Indian IT Outsourcing Giants At Crossroads As Trump Tightens Screws On Immigration

Indian IT Outsourcing Giants At Crossroads As Trump Tightens Screws On Immigration

The high-flying Indian IT outsourcing industry has withstood several challenges in the past. However, a recent obstacle has sent the industry into a tailspin, as these firms scurry around to identify strategies to work around the hindrance.

The industry — valued at over $150 billion and comprising companies such as Wipro Limited (ADR) (NYSE: WIT), Cognizant Technology Solutions Corp (NASDAQ: CTSH), Infosys Ltd ADR (NYSE: INFY) and Tata Consultancy Services — has thus far been competing effectively on certain unique selling propositions such as low-cost technology skills and high quality manpower.

Indian IT outsourcing was thriving on labor arbitrage, a concept that refers to the shifting of jobs where labor and the cost of doing business is inexpensive due to the reduction or removal of barriers to international trade. However, geopolitical developments across the globe, such as ongoing Brexit concerns, and radical industry shifts to new technologies like cloud computing have sounded out some warning signals to these firms.

Souring Indian Dreams

The most recent threat has come from a nation that has thus far accounted for over half of the industry's revenues. U.S. President Donald Trump's purported intention to clamp down on immigration and H-1B visas, which allows firms to bring in skilled foreign workers to the U.S. done with the intention of protecting the interest of American workers, signal trouble in paradise for these firms.

Some Statistics On The IT Outsourcing Industry

  • NASSCOM, the industry body, said in a recent strategic review report, that India continues to be the world's No.1 sourcing destination, with a 55 percent share.
  • The size of the Indian outsourcing industry is $108 billion.
  • It accounts for roughly 5 percent of India's GDP.
  • The industry employs over 3.7 million people.
  • U.S., the biggest market for Indian outsourcers, fetches these firms about 60 percent of their total revenues.
  • U.S. was the second largest source of remittance for India in 2015, accounting for $10.96 billion or about 16 percent of the total inflows, according to a CNBC report quoting Sonal Varma, chief Indian economists at Nomura.
  • 85 percent of the H-1B visas offered to the technology industry are given to Indian.


How H-1B Visas Work

H-1B visas are an employment-based, non-immigrant visa for temporary workers offered a job by an employer. In order to obtain the visa, one has to have at least a bachelors' degree. The filing for the coming fiscal year starts in April of the current year, and if the quota of 65,000 is filled, a lottery system would be enacted for allotment.

An additional 20,000 filings are allowed for qualified individuals who have completed their masters' program in the U.S.

What Trump Intends To Do With The Visa Clamp Down?

On April 18, Trump, through an executive order, ordered an interdepartmental review of the H-1B visa program with the intention of making changes to the program, either by way of regulation or by asking Congress to pass a bill.

The new administration has tried to project the H-1B program as a means used by business owners to hire cheap foreign labor and in the process denying jobs to qualified U.S. workers, thus substantiating its call for an overhaul.

A saving grace thus far has been the president's expressed views that the visa program should include only the most skilled and highest-paid applicants and should never aim at replacing American workers.

As baby steps toward a radical overhaul, the Trump administration announced the suspension of a practice that allowed visa processing within six weeks, if a higher fee is paid. It normally takes several months for the process to be complete. It was also hinted on the day visa applications opened for 2018 that the government would come down heavily on employers for hiring foreign workers to fill in jobs Americans can do.

Experts believe additional regulatory actions following the review could include raising salary thresholds and awarding visas to the most highly-educated and skilled applicants among those who qualify.

A Business Standard report, quoting Nomura Securities, said in July ahead of the U.S. presidential elections, "An H-1B crackdown under Donald Trump would lower the profitability of Indian IT companies (due to higher wage costs) while potential restrictions on business process outsourcing (BPO) could also hurt revenues."

Indian IT Majors Stare At Multiple Threats

Apart from the political threat, Indian IT giants are pressured by automation, making jobs redundant, and a shift in spending to newer areas such as digital and cloud computing.

Cloud computing, which allows accessing software and services through the internet, rather than on local networks, has helped to trim IT budgets of firms. CCServe said in a report that such a move could hurt profit growth at even India's most sophisticated software companies, as firms, government and consumers increase their computing on the cloud.

"It is only going to get cheaper and easier for companies to switch to the cloud, outsource providers need to get ready for the storm and modify their business models and move with the digital times," said Craig Ashmole, founding partner of London-based IT Consulting CCServe Ltd.

Meanwhile, automation has made labor arbitrage redundant on the lower end.

However, all these technologies prove to be a double-edged sword. When companies embrace them, they help to improve productivity and lower costs. At the same time, client-end adoption of the technologies introduces the risk of the companies' losing business.

Feeling The Pinch...Financially

Infosys recently reported its fiscal year fourth-quarter results, which showed a mere 0.9-percent sequential dollar revenue growth and it issued below-consensus dollar revenue growth guidance for the fiscal year 2018. The company's U.S. revenues were up a mere 1.2 percent. Peer TCS reported disappointing results for its March quarter, as growth and profitability suffered amid intense pricing pressure seen in commoditized outsourcing contracts.

Cognizant's fiscal year first-quarter profit and revenues exceeded estimates; however, it issued a soft revenue guidance for the June quarter, traditionally its strongest.

The companies find it tough to manage the pressure on margins, given that they are forced to deploy the more skilled people at the client end, with the adoption of protectionists policies by countries.

The industry has been living with single-digit revenue growth for some time now and is unable to kick-start growth in a big way amid the global macroeconomic and political uncertainties.


Countering The Encircling Threat

Some of these companies have announced local hiring to keep the Trump-threat at bay. Infosys said following the release of its March quarter results that it would hire about 10,000 people in the U.S. over the next two years. The company plans to open four innovation center hubs in the U.S.

Such an announcement is a blatant attempt to appease the Trump administration, given that the company is not in the habit of divulging information on countrywide hiring.

An report in India Today, quoting Head Hunters India founder K. Lakshmikanth, said Infosys might have to let go four of its Indian employees for hiring one person in the U.S., as the latter would bloat the costs. This is despite the company's assertion that jobs of Indians will be preserved.

Giving the economics, Lakshmikanth said, "All said and done, according to me, Infosys will take time to ramp up local hiring as it is very costly. The company needs to pay a minimum of $80,000 (Rs 52 lakh) per year to a skilled American techie."

"For the same amount, it can hire four software engineers in India for its offshore development work."

Even as this announcement from Infosys created a furor over its potential implication for jobs in India, Cognizant said recently it will rationalize its cost structure by bringing the employee base in line with demand. The company said on the earnings call it intends to ramp up hiring in the U.S., while at the same time reduce dependence on the H-1B visas.

The statement seems to explain the steep drop in the visa applications by the company this year.

Incidentally, the company also offered a voluntary severance scheme for its senior management, including directors and senior VPs, giving them the option of parting with a severance package of either six or nine months' pay, depending on the category.

In retaliation, some employees have taken up cudgels against the company's move to ease them out by lodging complaint with the local Labor Department.

Indian firms were not underprepared for the eventuality, if we go by a report in Quartz India.

Expecting things to come to this, companies have been trimming the number of H-1B visas they apply.

According to Myvisajobs, Infosys topped the list for the number of H-1B visa applications filed in fiscal year 2016, having filed 25,504 Labor Conditions Applications. This is down from the 33,289 LCAs it filed in the previous year. TCS also scaled back notably its LCA filings to 13,134 from 16,553.

A senior executive of a top Indian IT firm told Benzinga, on the condition of anonymity, that Indian companies have been bracing for an eventual tightening in visa norms by gradually increasing their local hiring over the recent years. However, on the cost front, the companies have to cough up three times the amount on salaries, although quality-wise there is very little difference in skill sets, except the slight edge local hires have in communication.

This communication advantage is seen to counterbalance the flexibility element the Indian workforce offers.

This, according, to the executive, would continue to hurt margins, and they have no recourse but to go back to their clients to hike the billings rates to preserve margins or alleviating margin pressure.

Near-Off Shore Sites: The 'In' Thing

Indian IT outsourcing firms are also exploring other options, including setting up near-shore centers or facilities closer to the U.S.

The executive said most companies have invested in near-offshore facilities, with Mexico being the most-sought-after center. Apart from the option helping to face the challenges of a protectionists environment in the U.S., the cost of doing business also comes down by roughly 50 percent.

Will Automation Ease Pressure?

Automation, according to the executive who spoke to Benzinga, could obviate some base levels positions, especially in business process outsourcing, with 15–20 percent jobs falling under this category. That said, the process of automation itself would require manpower, helping to offset the loss of jobs on the execution front.

All said and done, the Indian IT outsourcing industry is at a crossroads, working on efforts to shore up flat-lining revenue growth and shrinking margins, which are the offshoot of pricing pressure and rising costs. Towering on them is the challenge of upgrading to the next level of technology, the non-adoption of which could render them useless to clients.

On top of all these fundamental challenges, the protectionist policies being pursued in developed nations are also taking the wind out of their sails. The companies need to act fast in countering these challenges by changing their business models or face the risk of going into oblivion.

Related Links:

A Fundamental Case For India ETFs

Exposure To India Is Helping This Hedge Fund Reach All-Time Highs


Related Articles (CTSH + INFY)

View Comments and Join the Discussion!

Posted-In: Education Emerging Markets Politics Top Stories Economics Exclusives Markets Tech Best of Benzinga

Don't Miss Any Updates!
News Directly in Your Inbox
Subscribe to:
Benzinga Premarket Activity
Get pre-market outlook, mid-day update and after-market roundup emails in your inbox.
Market in 5 Minutes
Everything you need to know about the market - quick & easy.
Fintech Focus
A daily collection of all things fintech, interesting developments and market updates.
Everything you need to know about the latest SPAC news.
Thank You

Thank you for subscribing! If you have any questions feel free to call us at 1-877-440-ZING or email us at