Michael Montani's Stock Ratings

Evercore ISI Group Analyst

Michael Montani is an analyst at Evercore ISI Group. Analyst ratings are quantitative and qualitative analysis of a stock by Wall Street stock rating analysts. Stock ratings consist of expected future growth, current stock valuation and macroeconomic trends. Updated 12/16/2025

Updated: Dec 16, 2025

Overall Average Return

-0.80%

Smart Score

50.4%

Overall Average Return Percentile

31st

Number of Ratings

134
Buy NowGet Alert
12/09/2025KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52-8.69%$35 → $37MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/09/2025CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-7.56%$395 → $420MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/05/2025KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.3123.58%$80 → $77MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
12/05/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-4.05%$105 → $130MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/04/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-0.13%$175 → $180MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/02/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-22.5%$100 → $105MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/02/2025CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.5912.22%$585 → $610MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
11/11/2025ACIBuy Now
Albertsons Companies
$17.3421.11%$22 → $21MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
11/07/2025KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52-13.62%$52 → $35MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/30/2025CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-13.06%$425 → $395MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/21/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-2.9%$170 → $175MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/21/2025CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.597.62%$580 → $585MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
10/14/2025KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.3128.39%$82 → $80MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
10/07/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-11.22%$157 → $160MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/07/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-17.34%$114 → $112MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/02/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-12.89%$150 → $157MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/26/2025KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5228.33%$80 → $52DowngradeOutperform → In-LineGet Alert
09/23/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-15.86%$118 → $114MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/10/2025CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.596.7%$560 → $580MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
08/28/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-16.77%$134 → $150MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
08/26/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-25.65%$132 → $134MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
08/12/2025KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.3131.6%$80 → $82MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
08/12/2025KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5297.43%$82 → $80MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
08/12/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-26.76%$129 → $132MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
08/12/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-11.43%$118 → $120MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
08/12/2025CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-18.56%$365 → $370MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/24/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-33.42%$115 → $120MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/24/2025CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-32.87%$295 → $305MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/17/2025KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.3120.37%$76 → $75MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
06/17/2025CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-35.07%$290 → $295MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/05/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-36.19%$98 → $115MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/05/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-13.65%$105 → $117MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
05/28/2025KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52107.31%$85 → $84MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
05/28/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-45.63%$94 → $98MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
05/20/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-22.5%$100 → $105MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
05/14/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-26.19%$85 → $100MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
05/13/2025KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52109.77%$80 → $85MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
05/08/2025CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-38.37%$245 → $280MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/29/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-29.88%$90 → $95MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/17/2025ACIBuy Now
Albertsons Companies
$17.3426.87%$23 → $22MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/08/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-33.57%$85 → $90MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/01/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-50.06%$93 → $90MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/01/2025CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-15.38%$450 → $460MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/20/2025FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-48.4%$92 → $93MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/14/2025DGBuy Now
Dollar General
$135.49-37.26%$81 → $85MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/11/2025KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.3118.76%$73 → $74MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/11/2025KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52159.13%$107 → $105MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/11/2025CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-47.18%$250 → $240MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/11/2025CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-17.22%$460 → $450MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/11/2025ACIBuy Now
Albertsons Companies
$17.3426.87%$21 → $22MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
02/06/2025CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-37.27%$250 → $285MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
02/06/2025KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.3120.37%$70 → $75MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
12/13/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-13.54%$460 → $470MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
12/06/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.49-29.15%$95 → $96MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/03/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52104.84%$81 → $83MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/03/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.49-29.88%$97 → $95MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/03/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-46.08%$240 → $245MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
12/03/2024ACIBuy Now
Albertsons Companies
$17.349.57%$18 → $19MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/30/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-58.18%$186 → $190MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/22/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5287.56%$79 → $76MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/22/2024FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-42.3%$100 → $104MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/22/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.49-22.5%$115 → $105MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/22/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-59.94%$178 → $182MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/17/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5294.97%$76 → $79MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
10/16/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-19.06%$435 → $440MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
10/03/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5287.56%$79 → $76MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/27/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5294.97%$76 → $79MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/26/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-60.82%$178 → $178ReiteratesIn-Line → In-LineGet Alert
09/16/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-65.45%$142 → $157MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/13/2024KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.311.11%$62 → $63MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
08/30/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.49-26.19%$139 → $100MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
08/29/2024FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-47.29%$101 → $95MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
08/07/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-68.75%$150 → $142MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
07/29/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-19.98%$410 → $435MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
07/17/2024FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-37.3%$160 → $113DowngradeOutperform → In-LineGet Alert
07/16/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5277.69%$68 → $72MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
07/16/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-69.19%$135 → $140MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
07/16/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-24.57%$405 → $410MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
07/02/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.499.23%$151 → $148MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
07/02/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-70.29%$118 → $135MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/20/2024KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.31-3.71%$61 → $60MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
06/20/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5267.82%$73 → $68MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/20/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.4911.45%$150 → $151MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/20/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-74.03%$111 → $118MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/06/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5267.82%$72 → $68MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/16/2024KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.31-0.5%$63 → $62MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
04/16/2024FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.2324.84%$230 → $225MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
04/16/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-83.05%$78 → $77MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/16/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-36.53%$350 → $345MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
04/16/2024ACIBuy Now
Albertsons Companies
$17.3426.87%$23 → $22MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/12/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5282.63%$85 → $74MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/02/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.4918.09%$162 → $160MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/02/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-82.83%$75 → $78MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/02/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-35.61%$355 → $350MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/26/2024KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.312.71%$62 → $64MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/26/2024KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52109.77%$78 → $85MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/26/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.4919.57%$158 → $162MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/26/2024CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-83.49%$68 → $75MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/26/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-34.69%$345 → $355MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/21/2024FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.2327.61%$240 → $230MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/15/2024DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.4916.61%$165 → $158MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/14/2024DLTRBuy Now
Dollar Tree
$131.689.36%$157 → $144MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/13/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-37.08%$345 → $342MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/08/2024KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.31-0.5%$55 → $62MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
03/06/2024CASYBuy Now
Casey's General Stores
$543.59-36.53% → $345Initiates → OutperformGet Alert
01/04/2024FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.2335.94%$215 → $245UpgradeIn-Line → OutperformGet Alert
11/30/2023FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.2313.74%$200 → $205MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/25/2023KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5294.97%$80 → $79MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/08/2023FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.235.42%$195 → $190MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/08/2023DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.497.02%$150 → $145MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/08/2023CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-90.76%$40 → $42MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
09/01/2023DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.4910.71%$185 → $150DowngradeOutperform → NeutralGet Alert
08/31/2023FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.238.2%$205 → $195MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
07/20/2023CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-91.2%$24 → $40MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
06/16/2023KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.31-13.34%$56 → $54MaintainsOutperformGet Alert
05/26/2023DLTRBuy Now
Dollar Tree
$131.6817.71%$165 → $155MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/20/2023SFMBuy Now
Sprouts Farmers Market
$79.83-63.67% → $29Initiates → UnderperformGet Alert
12/23/2022KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.5248.08%$63 → $60MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
11/09/2022KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.31-10.13%$49 → $56UpgradeIn-Line → OutperformGet Alert
09/12/2022KRBuy Now
Kroger
$62.31-13.34%$51 → $54MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
04/21/2022CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-75.79%$155 → $110DowngradeOutperform → In-LineGet Alert
02/25/2022CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35-53.78% → $210UpgradeIn-Line → OutperformGet Alert
02/16/2022KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52196.15% → $120DowngradeOutperform → In-LineGet Alert
11/24/2021DLTRBuy Now
Dollar Tree
$131.6813.91%$125 → $150MaintainsIn-LineGet Alert
03/22/2021FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.2319.29% → $215DowngradeOutperform → In-LineGet Alert
03/22/2021DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.49——UpgradeIn-Line → OutperformGet Alert
01/28/2021ACIBuy Now
Albertsons Companies
$17.34——DowngradeOutperform → In-LineGet Alert
07/21/2020ACIBuy Now
Albertsons Companies
$17.34——Initiates → OutperformGet Alert
02/07/2020KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52——Initiates → OutperformGet Alert
02/07/2020CVNABuy Now
Carvana
$454.35——Initiates → In-LineGet Alert
03/20/2019DGBuy Now
Dollar Gen
$135.49——Initiates → UnderperformGet Alert
03/20/2019DLTRBuy Now
Dollar Tree
$131.68-20.26% → $105Initiates → In-LineGet Alert
03/20/2019FIVEBuy Now
Five Below
$180.23-22.32% → $140Initiates → OutperformGet Alert
03/17/2015KMXBuy Now
CarMax
$40.52——Initiates → BuyGet Alert