Homebuilder Stocks Tumble As Housing Starts Fall By 14.7%: 'A Poor Time To Buy A Home,' Says Economist

Homebuilder stocks face sharp declines as the SPDR Homebuilders ETF XHB drops 1.8% in Tuesday’s session, hitting its lowest level since Feb. 26, 2024, amid negative economic data.

From the start of the month, this performance gauge has fallen approximately 10%, marking the first market correction since September 2023 after a significant 60% rally in the six months leading up to late March.

Tuesday’s worst performers among U.S. homebuilder stocks were Installed Building Products, Inc. IBP, TopBuild Corp. BLD, Dream Finders Homes, Inc. DFH

Sharp Decline in Housing Starts Signals Market Cooling

In the U.S., housing starts in March 2024 saw a dramatic month-over-month decrease of 14.7%, reaching an annualized rate of 1.321 million.

This figure not only represents the steepest drop since April 2020, but also sits substantially below the anticipated 1.48 million, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau.

The decline spans across single-family homes, which decreased by 12.4% to 1.022 million, and units in buildings with five or more units, which fell by 20.8% to 290,000.

Regional Breakdown:

Northeast: Decreased by 36% to 80,000
Midwest: Decreased by 23% to 157,000
South: Decreased by 17.8% to 736,000
West: Increased by 7.1% to 348,000

Building Permits Also Show Decrease

March 2024 building permits dropped by 4.3% to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.458 million, reversing a 2.3% rise in February and missing forecasts of 1.514 million.

This marks the lowest level since July of the previous year. Single-family authorizations also declined by 5.7% to a five-month low of 973,000.

Regional Insights:

South: Slight decrease of 0.6% to 771,000
Midwest: Sharp decrease of 14.7% to 197,000
Northeast: Steep decline of 20.8% to 160,000
West: Gained 5.1% to 330,000

Analyst Insights: Slowing Growth and Future Concerns

Jeffrey Roach, chief economist for LPL Financial, highlights that housing starts dropped in March and “are starting to show cracks in the pace of growth.”

The economist expects significant slowing, particularly in multifamily construction. He warns that the decline in building permits suggests a future slowdown in building activity.

“Housing construction is poised to slow as potential homebuyers indicate now is a poor time to buy a home. Investors should expect residential investment becoming a drag on GDP growth in the coming quarters,” Roach wrote.

Bill Adams, chief economist for Comerica Bank, points out the impact of high interest rates, especially on the credit-intensive multifamily segment. Despite a year-over-year increase in starts and permits in the first quarter, the sector shows clear signs of cooling due to rising borrowing costs.

“In the first quarter as a whole, housing starts rose 2.1% from a year earlier but fell an annualized 17.5% from the fourth quarter of 2023. Building permits rose 4.6% on the year in the first quarter and were up 1.1% annualized on the quarter,” he stated.

The multifamily segment of homebuilding is experiencing the most significant slowdown. Typically, these developments are intended for leasing and depend on long-term debt financing.

However, as the Federal Reserve has increased interest rates, the cost of this financing has risen sharply.

Bottom line, the housing market faces continued pressure from rising mortgage rates and economic uncertainty, and the homebuilding sector’s recent downturn might signal a broader cooling.

With experts predicting residential investment to drag on GDP growth, the market may not stabilize until the Federal Reserve adjusts its monetary policy.

Homebuilders and investors should brace for challenging quarters ahead as potential homebuyers are increasingly viewing this period as a poor time to buy a home.

Chart: Housing Starts and Building Permits (% month-over-month)