Market Overview

CBOE Buying Bats Makes Sense, Just Not Strategically

Share:
CBOE Buying Bats Makes Sense, Just Not Strategically
Related CBOE
CBOE Holdings Announces Pricing of $300 Million Senior Notes
Bull of the Day: CBOE Holdings (CBOE)
Related
Citigroup Reinstates Coverage Of Bats Global Markets Ahead Of Q3 Earnings
Analysts See Risks To EPS Upside From CBOE-Bats Deal

CLSA does not believe CBOE Holdings, Inc (NASDAQ: CBOE) acquiring Bats Global Markets Inc (BATS: BATS) for $32.50 a share would fit strategically, although the acquisition makes sense. Therefore, the firm has an Underperform rating and a price target of $68 on the company's stock.

While pointing out that the offer price was much less than what analyst Rob Rutschow estimated, the expected synergies from the acquisition confirmed the brokerage's fear about fewer synergies. Rutschow liked the company's preference of using debt for the acquisition.

The analyst sees two primary factors in favor of CBOE. One is the company could stop creating its next-gen trading platform vector as he expects the company spending about $50 million. This also has the potential of some elevated costs in the next two-year period. The second factor is that the company could effectively shun a fresh competitor besides tough pricing conditions in options.

Related Link: Buckingham Research Upgrades CBOE Holdings To Buy, Raises PT To $77

In a research note to clients, the brokerage said, "However, we feel that the addition of BATS' franchise makes CBOE a much less attractive target (particularly to CME), which could result in the combined firm losing some of the merger premium CBOE enjoyed previously (which was a 3–6 PE point premium to CME)."

CLSA believes this would drag down pro-forma PE from 23x to 20x the pro-forma earnings mix. Though the firm expects the combination to report adjusted EPS of nearly $3 in 2017 compared to its estimate of $2.55 for CBOE, the brokerage does not expect much improvement in the following years.

At time of writing, the stock traded at $67.00, up $0.41, or 0.62 percent.

Full ratings data available on Benzinga Pro.

Do you have ideas for articles/interviews you'd like to see more of on Benzinga? Please email feedback@benzinga.com with your best article ideas. One person will be randomly selected to win a $20 Amazon gift card!

Latest Ratings for CBOE

DateFirmActionFromTo
Jul 2017JefferiesMaintainsHold
Jul 2017CitigroupInitiates Coverage OnNeutral
Jan 2017Bank of AmericaUpgradesUnderperformBuy

View More Analyst Ratings for CBOE
View the Latest Analyst Ratings

Posted-In: Analyst Color News Short Ideas Price Target Reiteration M&A Analyst Ratings Trading Ideas Best of Benzinga

 

Related Articles (CBOE + BATS)

View Comments and Join the Discussion!