Strategic, Financial Rationale Of Tesla-SolarCity Deal Unconvincing

Tesla Motors Inc TSLA announced it has offered to acquire SolarCity Corp SCTY in an all-stock deal valued at $26.50-$28.50 per share. RBC Capital Markets’ Joseph Spak commented that the proposed transaction is unlikely to be “well-received” by Tesla’s shareholders.

The deal represents a 21-30 premium over Tuesday’s closing price and values SolarCity at $2.6-$2.8bn. The market is likely to be skeptical of the strategic rationale and the strain on Tesla’s financials and cash flow.

“TSLA is billing themselves as a “sustainable energy” company, but we believe they need to do a better job convincing the market as to why this deal makes strategic (and financial) sense,” Spak said.

Related Link: JPMorgan On Tesla/SolarCity Deal: 'You Can't Put The Genie Back Into The Bottle'

More Questions Than Answers

Currently there is a great deal of uncertainty related to the transaction. Spak enumerated the points to consider as:

  • While some customers may be interested in electric vehicles and storage products, there may not be meaningful cross-sell opportunities
  • Unsure whether Tesla really needs to own the asset, since the companies already have relationships.
  • SolarCity’s acquisition would not help Tesla’s cash burn. “Related, we need to better understand the financial constraints this puts on TSLA,” the analyst wrote.
  • The sustainability of the SolarCity model could be challenged, especially if storage costs do not decline dramatically
  • “Better explanation of the inter-company “dealings” and of Musk’s pledged SCTY shares (4mm) as collateral to his personal credit lines as investors could question governance,” Spak added.

The analyst has a Sector Perform for Tesla, with a price target of $242.

Market News and Data brought to you by Benzinga APIs
Comments
Loading...
date
ticker
name
Price Target
Upside/Downside
Recommendation
Firm
Posted In: Analyst ColorReiterationAnalyst RatingsJoseph SpakRBC Capital Markets
Benzinga simplifies the market for smarter investing

Trade confidently with insights and alerts from analyst ratings, free reports and breaking news that affects the stocks you care about.

Join Now: Free!