Bulls vs Bears
Click to unlock major analysts' bullish and bearish positions by joining Benzinga Edge.
Click to unlock major analysts' bullish and bearish positions by joining Benzinga Edge.
Selective Insurance Group Inc has a consensus price target of $99 based on the ratings of 12 analysts. The high is $120 issued by Oppenheimer on April 5, 2024. The low is $85 issued by Piper Sandler on July 22, 2024. The 3 most-recent analyst ratings were released by Morgan Stanley, Keefe, Bruyette & Woods, and BMO Capital on May 19, 2025, April 30, 2025, and April 29, 2025, respectively. With an average price target of $92.67 between Morgan Stanley, Keefe, Bruyette & Woods, and BMO Capital, there's an implied 8.87% upside for Selective Insurance Group Inc from these most-recent analyst ratings.
1calculated from analyst ratings
Buy Now | Get Alert | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
05/19/2025 | Buy Now | 5.73% | Morgan Stanley | Bob Huang62% | $85 → $90 | Maintains | Equal-Weight | Get Alert |
04/30/2025 | Buy Now | 8.08% | Keefe, Bruyette & Woods | Meyer Shields77% | $93 → $92 | Maintains | Market Perform | Get Alert |
04/29/2025 | Buy Now | 12.78% | BMO Capital | Michael Zaremski70% | $92 → $96 | Maintains | Outperform | Get Alert |
02/07/2025 | Buy Now | 9.26% | Keefe, Bruyette & Woods | Meyer Shields77% | $116 → $93 | Downgrade | Outperform → Market Perform | Get Alert |
02/03/2025 | Buy Now | 2.21% | Morgan Stanley | Bob Huang62% | $95 → $87 | Maintains | Equal-Weight | Get Alert |
01/30/2025 | Buy Now | — | JMP Securities | Karol Chmiel78% | — | Reiterates | Market Perform → Market Perform | Get Alert |
01/10/2025 | Buy Now | 36.28% | Keefe, Bruyette & Woods | Meyer Shields77% | $114 → $116 | Maintains | Outperform | Get Alert |
12/05/2024 | Buy Now | 23.36% | Morgan Stanley | Bob Huang62% | → $105 | Initiates | → Equal-Weight | Get Alert |
10/30/2024 | Buy Now | 23.36% | BMO Capital | Michael Zaremski70% | $95 → $105 | Upgrade | Market Perform → Outperform | Get Alert |
10/23/2024 | Buy Now | 16.31% | RBC Capital | Scott Heleniak79% | $96 → $99 | Maintains | Sector Perform | Get Alert |
10/22/2024 | Buy Now | 19.83% | B of A Securities | Grace Carter68% | $96 → $102 | Maintains | Underperform | Get Alert |
10/10/2024 | Buy Now | 12.78% | B of A Securities | Grace Carter68% | $89 → $96 | Maintains | Underperform | Get Alert |
07/24/2024 | Buy Now | 11.61% | BMO Capital | Michael Zaremski70% | $92 → $95 | Maintains | Market Perform | Get Alert |
07/23/2024 | Buy Now | — | JMP Securities | Matthew Carletti84% | — | Reiterates | → Market Perform | Get Alert |
07/22/2024 | Buy Now | 12.78% | RBC Capital | Scott Heleniak79% | $103 → $96 | Maintains | Sector Perform | Get Alert |
07/22/2024 | Buy Now | -0.14% | Piper Sandler | Paul Newsome82% | $104 → $85 | Maintains | Neutral | Get Alert |
07/22/2024 | Buy Now | 16.31% | Keefe, Bruyette & Woods | Meyer Shields77% | $104 → $99 | Upgrade | Market Perform → Outperform | Get Alert |
07/11/2024 | Buy Now | 13.96% | B of A Securities | Grace Carter68% | $98 → $97 | Maintains | Underperform | Get Alert |
06/24/2024 | Buy Now | 21.01% | RBC Capital | Scott Heleniak79% | $103 → $103 | Reiterates | Sector Perform → Sector Perform | Get Alert |
04/15/2024 | Buy Now | — | JMP Securities | Matthew Carletti84% | — | Reiterates | → Market Perform | Get Alert |
04/05/2024 | Buy Now | 40.98% | Oppenheimer | Michael Phillips54% | $120 → $120 | Maintains | Outperform | Get Alert |
04/01/2024 | Buy Now | 22.18% | Piper Sandler | Paul Newsome82% | → $104 | Maintains | Neutral | Get Alert |
02/06/2024 | Buy Now | 28.05% | Keefe, Bruyette & Woods | Meyer Shields77% | $111 → $109 | Maintains | Market Perform | Get Alert |
02/02/2024 | Buy Now | 23.36% | RBC Capital | Scott Heleniak79% | $108 → $105 | Maintains | Sector Perform | Get Alert |
11/16/2023 | Buy Now | 40.98% | Oppenheimer | Michael Phillips54% | → $120 | Initiates | → Outperform | Get Alert |
11/03/2023 | Buy Now | 26.88% | RBC Capital | Scott Heleniak79% | $105 → $108 | Maintains | Sector Perform | Get Alert |
10/06/2023 | Buy Now | 24.53% | Piper Sandler | Paul Newsome82% | $112 → $106 | Maintains | Neutral | Get Alert |
08/04/2023 | Buy Now | 23.36% | RBC Capital | Mark Dwelle82% | $100 → $105 | Maintains | Sector Perform | Get Alert |
07/25/2023 | Buy Now | 29.23% | Piper Sandler | Paul Newsome82% | $102 → $110 | Maintains | Neutral | Get Alert |
07/25/2023 | Buy Now | 17.48% | B of A Securities | Grace Carter68% | $93 → $100 | Maintains | Underperform | Get Alert |
07/25/2023 | Buy Now | 17.48% | RBC Capital | Mark Dwelle82% | → $100 | Reiterates | Sector Perform → Sector Perform | Get Alert |
07/06/2023 | Buy Now | 19.83% | Piper Sandler | Paul Newsome82% | $104 → $102 | Maintains | Neutral | Get Alert |
06/14/2023 | Buy Now | 9.26% | BMO Capital | Michael Zaremski70% | $90 → $93 | Maintains | Market Perform | Get Alert |
05/18/2023 | Buy Now | — | B of A Securities | Grace Carter68% | — | Downgrade | Neutral → Underperform | Get Alert |
05/16/2023 | Buy Now | 24.53% | Keefe, Bruyette & Woods | Meyer Shields77% | $104 → $106 | Maintains | Market Perform | Get Alert |
05/05/2023 | Buy Now | 17.48% | RBC Capital | Mark Dwelle82% | $96 → $100 | Maintains | Sector Perform | Get Alert |
04/18/2023 | Buy Now | 22.18% | Keefe, Bruyette & Woods | Meyer Shields77% | $107 → $104 | Maintains | Market Perform | Get Alert |
04/04/2023 | Buy Now | 25.7% | Piper Sandler | Paul Newsome82% | $104 → $107 | Maintains | Neutral | Get Alert |
02/14/2023 | Buy Now | 25.7% | Keefe, Bruyette & Woods | Meyer Shields77% | $105 → $107 | Maintains | Market Perform | Get Alert |
02/06/2023 | Buy Now | 12.78% | RBC Capital | Mark Dwelle82% | $90 → $96 | Maintains | Sector Perform | Get Alert |
01/20/2023 | Buy Now | 5.73% | BMO Capital | Michael Zaremski70% | → $90 | Initiates | → Market Perform | Get Alert |
11/22/2022 | Buy Now | 23.36% | Morgan Stanley | Michael Phillips54% | $98 → $105 | Maintains | Overweight | Get Alert |
11/11/2022 | Buy Now | 12.78% | Janney Montgomery Scott | Robert Farnam67% | → $96 | Initiates | → Neutral | Get Alert |
06/27/2022 | Buy Now | 15.13% | Morgan Stanley | Michael Phillips54% | → $98 | Initiates | → Overweight | Get Alert |
The latest price target for Selective Insurance Gr (NASDAQ:SIGI) was reported by Morgan Stanley on May 19, 2025. The analyst firm set a price target for $90.00 expecting SIGI to rise to within 12 months (a possible 5.73% upside). 19 analyst firms have reported ratings in the last year.
The latest analyst rating for Selective Insurance Gr (NASDAQ:SIGI) was provided by Morgan Stanley, and Selective Insurance Gr maintained their equal-weight rating.
The last upgrade for Selective Insurance Group Inc happened on October 30, 2024 when BMO Capital raised their price target to $105. BMO Capital previously had a market perform for Selective Insurance Group Inc.
The last downgrade for Selective Insurance Group Inc happened on February 7, 2025 when Keefe, Bruyette & Woods changed their price target from $116 to $93 for Selective Insurance Group Inc.
Analysts arrive at stock ratings after doing extensive research, which includes going through public financial statements, talking to executives and customers of Selective Insurance Gr, and listening in to earnings conference calls. Most analysts do this every three months, so you should get 4 ratings per company per firm each year. The last rating for Selective Insurance Gr was filed on May 19, 2025 so you should expect the next rating to be made available sometime around May 19, 2026.
While ratings are subjective and will change, the latest Selective Insurance Gr (SIGI) rating was a maintained with a price target of $85.00 to $90.00. The current price Selective Insurance Gr (SIGI) is trading at is $85.12, which is within the analyst’s predicted range.
Browse analyst ratings and price targets on all stocks.
A newsletter built for market enthusiasts by market enthusiasts. Top stories, top movers, and trade ideas delivered to your inbox every weekday before and after the market closes.