Matthew Green, a cryptography professor at Johns Hopkins University, has expressed his concerns about the security of Telegram compared to Signal. Green’s concerns have now been endorsed by Signal president Meredith Whittaker.
What Happened: Over the weekend, Green took to X, formerly Twitter, to voice his concerns about Telegram’s security measures.
“Telegram has launched a pretty intense campaign to malign Signal as insecure, with assistance from Elon Musk. The goal seems to be to get activists to switch away from encrypted Signal to mostly unencrypted Telegram,” he stated.
Green pointed out that Telegram does not end-to-end encrypt conversations by default, making all data visible on its server. He highlighted the open-source nature of Signal’s client code, which allows for extensive review by experts, making it a more secure option.
The cryptographer also criticized Telegram CEO Pavel Durov for promoting the platform as more secure than Signal, despite its lack of default end-to-end encryption. “This is like promoting ketchup as better for your car than synthetic motor oil. Telegram isn't a secure messenger, full stop.”
He also addressed Durov’s claim that Signal doesn’t have reproducible builds, stating that Signal has these for Android, and it’s a relatively simple process.
“It's not weird for a CEO to say ‘My product is better than your product.’ But when the claim is about security and critically, *you've made a deliberate decision not to add security for most users* then it exists the domain of competition, and starts to feel like malice,” he stated.
Green’s thread was shared by Meredith Whittaker, the president of Signal Foundation, who endorsed his views on the differences between Signal and Telegram. She described Green as an “expert's expert.”
Subscribe to the Benzinga Tech Trends newsletter to get all the latest tech developments delivered to your inbox.
Why It Matters: This debate over the security of messaging platforms comes at a time when the use of secure messaging apps is on the rise. Last month, in an interview with conservative media figure Tucker Carlson, Durov disclosed that Telegram is gaining 2.5 million new users daily.
When asked about rumors suggesting that “Telegram is affiliated with the Russian government,” Durov said, “People who have very limited knowledge of where Telegram came from… they would make these claims. They could be encouraged by our competitors, who see it as an easy way to discredit us.”
He went on to say that his rivals invest tens of billions in marketing and are recognized for employing public relations firms for such campaigns. “I’m not surprised there’s this sort of perception.”
Just last week, Musk faced fact-checking on X after he raised concerns regarding the security of Signal. “There are known vulnerabilities with Signal that are not being addressed. Seems odd…”
The tech mogul’s post prompted a response from Signal’s president Whittaker, who refuted the existence of any security vulnerabilities but also highlighted the company’s prompt resolution of legitimate issues.
Check out more of Benzinga’s Consumer Tech coverage by following this link.
Disclaimer: This content was partially produced with the help of Benzinga Neuro and was reviewed and published by Benzinga editors.
Photo via Shutterstock
© 2024 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.
Trade confidently with insights and alerts from analyst ratings, free reports and breaking news that affects the stocks you care about.
