'I Got Scammed': Americans Hit With Unexpected Bills Because Of Healthcare Loophole

Surprise medical bills have long plagued the U.S. healthcare system, and despite recent efforts by Congress to address the issue, patients continue to find themselves caught in a web of unexpected charges. One such case is that of Anthony, a 29-year-old resident of Norwalk, Connecticut, who was hit with a $132 bill after what should have been a routine annual checkup.

According to Yahoo Finance, the root cause of Anthony's surprise bill was a simple coding error by his doctor's office, which classified the visit as an "office visit" instead of an "annual checkup or preventative care." The mistake resulted in Anthony being held responsible for the bill, despite his insurance plan through Cigna Healthcare promising 100% coverage without a copay for preventive visits. Frustrated and confused, Anthony reached out to both Cigna and his doctor's office to rectify the situation, only to be met with rejection and conflicting explanations.

Don't Miss:

"I submitted a complaint to Westmed, and they forwarded it to the billing department," Anthony recounted to Yahoo! Finance. "They rejected my request several times. According to them, the office staff had the final word on the billing code. I was able to talk to the office staff directly, too, but I’m not sure who was responsible for selecting the billing code there."

Anthony further described his experience, stating, "Wasted a bunch of time, and frankly, I got scammed. In the end, I got no explanation why they used the wrong code, and the bill was sent to collections. It's going to hurt my credit score and in the U.S., that also means my ability to find a place to rent or even buy a house if I ever get the chance. It's the kind of thing you lose sleep over."

Anthony's experience is not an isolated incident but rather a symptom of a larger problem rooted in the Affordable Care Act (ACA). While the ACA mandates coverage for preventive services without cost-sharing, the specific coding and operationalization of these services are left to individual insurers. Consequently, patients often find themselves billed for services that should be free under the ACA's provisions.

In this landscape of healthcare challenges, innovative solutions are needed to address the underlying issues. Most notably, retail giant Amazon.com, Inc. has continued to expand its generic pharmacy business. And Mark Cuban’s Cost Plus Drugs Co. has been gaining traction in reducing prescription drug prices. Other firms like Bioverge, a venture capital fund aimed toward retail investors, continues to invest in healthcare-based technologies to help correct disparities in the U.S. healthcare system.

The significance of healthcare coding and billing for the financial stability of medical practices has been highlighted in a recent article posted by the National Library of Medicine. Emphasizing the need for resident and faculty physicians to possess the necessary knowledge and skills, the article discusses common issues identified through a systematic review of published studies. These issues include the lack of formal education in residency programs, insufficient clinical documentation and the absence of feedback systems to correct billing errors.

To stay updated with top startup news & investments, sign up for Benzinga's Startup Investing & Equity Crowdfunding Newsletter

The article concludes that implementing a formal education curriculum during training could greatly improve the accuracy of coding and billing practices, leading to enhanced practice longevity. But challenges in the healthcare system contribute to the persistence of surprise medical bills. 

A 2021 study published in the journal Preventive Medicine revealed that Americans with employer-sponsored insurance paid millions of dollars for preventive services that should have been covered by their premiums. This discrepancy arises from the interpretation of rules and varying procedure codes used by insurers to determine coverage eligibility.

A ruling by Judge Reed O'Connor, who previously deemed the ACA unconstitutional (later overturned by the Supreme Court), found it unconstitutional to require insurers to cover preventive services without copayments. This ruling, if upheld, could lead to a significant portion of adults opting out of paying for preventive services mandated by the ACA. Insurance companies' short-term focus and prioritization of market share also contribute to the problem, as they often fail to consider the long-term well-being of their customers.

Efforts to address surprise medical bills, such as the No Surprises Act, have been made, but loopholes in the legislation persist. While patients are protected from surprise bills from out-of-network providers and emergency services, the same protection does not apply to in-network providers, regardless of whether the services should be covered without cost-sharing.

Advocates and healthcare policy experts argue that these gaps in the healthcare system require closer scrutiny from policymakers, employers and the media. Patients frequently face unexpected charges for routine procedures that should be fully covered by their insurance and often are required to sign forms acknowledging the possibility of separate billing for an office visit and a preventive health exam.

Surprise medical bills affect patients' financial well-being and have broader consequences, including negative impacts on credit scores and future housing prospects. As legislative efforts have not fully addressed the issue, a comprehensive solution is needed to protect patients from the financial burden of surprise medical bills.

See more on startup investing from Benzinga:

Market News and Data brought to you by Benzinga APIs
Posted In: NewsHealth CareStartupshealthcarestartup crowdfunding
Benzinga simplifies the market for smarter investing

Trade confidently with insights and alerts from analyst ratings, free reports and breaking news that affects the stocks you care about.

Join Now: Free!