Amid uncertain times in the market, the flow of investments into ETFs is revealing a split in portfolio strategies, one that goes beyond just asset allocation and taps into the very behavior of investors.

The contrast between the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF VOO and the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF SCHD shows a key change in how market players are positioning themselves for today's economic situation: some are doubling down on long-term growth, while others are tilting towards quality income-generating assets.

Also Read: This New ETF Aims To Turn GameStop’s Wild Moves Into Cash

VOO's Long-Term Growth Thesis

VOO, which tracks the returns of the S&P 500 index, has pulled in more than $65 billion in inflows year-to-date as of May 30, including a staggering $21 billion just in April, according to a report by Zacks Research.

At the end of the first quarter, total assets in the ETF were $1.3 trillion. With total assets now beyond $1.3 trillion, VOO has claimed the title of the largest ETF in the world. This shows a growing preference among investors for low-cost, broad-market exposure.

What's causing this influx isn't just VOO's remarkably low expense ratio of 0.03%, but also a renewed faith in mega-cap tech stocks and growth sectors that dominate the S&P 500.

Investors seem to be taking tariff threats and policy fluctuations in stride. Ongoing cycles of proposed trade restrictions show that they are considering the events as chances to "buy the dip," a behavior in line with historical trends.

SCHD Retains Core Dividend-Focused Base

While SCHD hasn't experienced inflows on the same scale, it still enjoys attention from investors, especially those focused on income and risk aversion. As of today, SCHD's assets are around $70 billion, buoyed by a 4% trailing 12-month dividend yield and a remarkable 13-year history of consistent dividend payments and growth.

SCHD specializes in quality metrics such as return on equity, free cash flow to debt and a decade-long consistency in dividends, making it a more value-driven choice. Its sector allocation leans toward industrials, healthcare and consumer staples, which cushion the portfolio during turbulent times.

Growth Seekers Vs. Yield Builders

The widening gap between VOO and SCHD speaks of two very different investor mindsets.

VOO investors are all about long-term capital growth, keeping fees low and enjoying full market exposure. They typically embrace an "accumulate and hold" approach, often reinvesting dividends automatically to take advantage of compounding returns.

On the flip side, SCHD investors are more into current income generation and capital preservation. This group often includes retirees or conservative investors who want to settle into stability.

Recession Protection Vs. Bull Market Participation

Over the past decade, a $10,000 investment in VOO has more than tripled to over $33,000, while SCHD has reached around $27,000, assuming dividends were reinvested. However, SCHD has typically experienced smaller losses during market downturns, thanks to its defensive sector focus and its avoidance of REITs and non-dividend-paying stocks.

Additionally, SCHD's 100% Qualified Dividend Income (QDI) status in 2024 gives it a tax efficiency moat, making it especially likeable for taxable accounts. VOO's QDI is also impressive at 97.33% in 2025, primarily due to its minimal exposure to REITs, however, there is a clear winner in this area.

A Shift Toward Barbell Portfolio Construction?

More and more investors, VOO and SCHD aren't seen as opposing choices but rather as complementary options. There's a growing trend toward "barbell" strategies, which combine high-growth investments with dependable dividend income to reduce downside risk while still allowing for upside potential.

As financial markets steer around ongoing policy-driven fluctuations, the differences between these two ETFs may become even more pronounced, providing insight into how various investor profiles are reshaping the concept of "passive" investing in 2025.

Read Next: