Market Overview

Bernstein Still Thinks Bayer-Monsanto Takeover Is A Huge Stretch

Bernstein Still Thinks Bayer-Monsanto Takeover Is A Huge Stretch
Related MON
Blue Apron, Boeing, Chipotle, Monsanto: Fast Money Picks For September 21
What Pharmaceuticals Spend On Lobbying To Influence Trump
John Paulson Buys Vistra Energy Corp, Altaba Inc, T-Mobile US Inc, Sells Extended Stay America ... (GuruFocus)

Monsanto Company (NYSE: MON) has received an unsolicited, non-binding proposal to be acquired by Bayer. Bernstein’s Jeremy Redenius maintained an Underperform rating for Monsanto, with a price target of $80.

Commenting that the deal appears to be “a big financial stretch,” analyst Jeremy Redenius mentioned that a merger followed by a spin-off of a NewAgCo may create more value. There are no comments from Monsanto, since its Board of Directors are still reviewing the proposal.

Financial Stretch

Redenius said that the deal is only EPS breakeven, at an offer price of $108 per share, which represents a 20 percent to the undisturbed price. He added that the acquisition ROIC was unlikely to cover Bayer's cost of capital until at least 2025. “This was based on our synergy expectations of €1.5B, Bayer raising €15B in debt, with the remainder €27B coming in equity.”

The analyst believes that Bayer would have to offer a price closer to $120-%125 per share to complete the deal. This represents a premium of 35-40 percent. Even in this scenario, if Bayer is able to fund an additional €5 billion in cash through the sale of Animal Health, and record synergies of $2 billion, the deal would still be accretive by only 3-4 percent by 2020.

Rather than an outright acquisition, a merger-split similar to the Dow-DuPont deal is likely to create more value, Redenius said.

Latest Ratings for MON

Aug 2017UBSDowngradesBuyNeutral
Jul 2017JefferiesDowngradesBuyHold
Jun 2017SusquehannaDowngradesPositiveNeutral

View More Analyst Ratings for MON
View the Latest Analyst Ratings

Posted-In: Bernstein Jeremy RedeniusAnalyst Color Short Ideas Reiteration Analyst Ratings Trading Ideas Best of Benzinga


Related Articles (MON)

View Comments and Join the Discussion!