Your Old Pokemon, Hot Wheels And Beanie Babies Could Be Worth $1,000 Or More — Here's How To Find Out

Toys that were once just childhood amusements are emerging as real investment assets, albeit unpredictable ones.

While access to online marketplaces has contributed to the rise in investing in toys, the number of sites like eBay, Etsy, Whatnot and auction houses has proliferated, legitimizing the resale market.

Here's how you can tell if an old plaything is just a toy or a treasure waiting to be discovered.

Don't Miss:

• The ‘ChatGPT of Marketing' Just Opened a $0.81/Share Round — 10,000+ Investors Are Already In
• Wall Street's $12B Real Estate Manager Is Opening Its Doors to Individual Investors — Without the Crowdfunding Middlemen

Nostalgia Rising as an Alternative Investment Strategy

Gen X and millennials are driving the rise in toy collecting, according to collectible gear protection company Vanity Slabs. Buffeted in their youth by economic uncertainty, stock market crashes, rapid technological change and a global financial crisis, Gen X and millennials embrace nostalgia in search of a respite from the rush of their adult worlds.

Investors in these age groups, facing continued economic uncertainty, inflation and tariffs, often choose to reach back to the tangible things of childhood for comfort. Their emotional connection to the past drives demand for toy collectibles.

Gen X and millennials mainly buy toys for nostalgia and childhood memories, whether as a hobby or as an investment strategy, research company CivicScience reports.

What to Look for With Pokémon, Hot Wheels and Beanie Babies

If you are seeking financial gain from your collectible toys, here's what to look for:

Pokémon

A full set of first-edition holofoils released in 1995 could be worth about $8,500, according to The Collector. Misprinted Krabby cards, missing the fossil symbol at the bottom right, can fetch about $5,000, and limited releases of 15 cards or fewer could pull in $10,000.

Trending: Buffett's Secret to Wealth? Private Real Estate—Get Institutional Access Yourself

Hot Wheels

Hot Wheels from the 1960s and 1970s can sell for thousands of dollars, including the Volkswagen Customs that can sell for $1,500, the 1971 Olds 442 in purple, pink or salmon that can go for $1,000 or the 1970 Mad Maverick that can fetch $15,000, according to The Collector.

Only two 1969 Pink Rear-Loading VW Bus Beach Bombs from Hot Wheels exist, and renowned Hot Wheels collector Bruce Pascal owns one valued at $175,000, according to Hot Cars. At that price, you could own and drive two of the top-selling 1969 VW buses today and have enough cash left over to buy a brand-new 2025 VW Jetta, based on estimated car values from Kelley Blue Book.

Beanie Babies

Beanie Babies that had limited runs or that have tag errors can drive prices up, says The Collector. For example, Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant had a short run when its color was changed to light blue. Patti the Platypus was from the original Beanie Babies released in 1993. Additionally, the 1997 version of Claude the Crab had errors.

The majority of these toys may not be worth much, but a few of them may be gems that deliver a big payoff.

Spotting Value for Your Collection

To build value in your toy collection, be strategic and focus on rarity, condition, demand and any kind of documentation that should accompany a toy.

See Also: 7 Million Gamers Already Trust Gameflip With Their Digital Assets — Now You Can Own a Stake in the Platform

Follow these practical tips:

• Seek first editions, limited runs and retired versions.
• Check the condition and packaging.
• Look up the sold listings on eBay, not the asking price.
• Research historical significance and prior ownership.
• Store your toy properly to protect it from damage.

A toy may be valuable on its own. However, having it graded could increase its value significantly. Consider using a reputable service, such as the Collectible Grading Authority or one of its subsidiaries: the Action Figure Authority, Collectible Doll Authority, Die-Cast Authority and Video Game Authority. 

Other reputable services include Collector Archive Services, Certified Guaranty Company, Beckett Authentication Services and Professional Sports Authenticator.

Understand the Risks and Watch for Scams

Fluctuating demand and changing pop culture trends make the toy collecting market volatile. For example, Beanie Babies values climbed in the mid to late 90s before crashing amid panic selling after Ty Inc. announced all Beanie Babies would be retired, according to History.com.

Also, stay alert to the possibility of fake listings, counterfeit products or scams.

Because the value of your toys may be tied to trends, consider collecting toys for the enjoyment value and the financial value, instead of pure speculation.

Collect for Nostalgia First

Collecting toys may not fatten your wallet, boost your bank account or increase your net worth, but if you collect for nostalgia first, whether the value of your toy rises or falls, you'll appreciate the joy it gives you.

Read Next: From Chipotle to Red Bull, Top Brands Are Already Building With Modern Mill's Tree-Free Wood Alternative — Here's How You Can Invest Too

Image: Shutterstock