Witnessing An Insider Decision, Malynda West Exercises Options Valued At $1.27M At Murphy USA

In a new SEC filing on August 13, it was revealed that West, EVP & Chief Operating Officer at Murphy USA (NYSE:MUSA), executed a significant exercise of company stock options.

What Happened: A Form 4 filing from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on Wednesday showed that West, EVP & Chief Operating Officer at Murphy USA, a company in the Consumer Discretionary sector, just exercised stock options worth 4,100 shares of MUSA stock with an exercise price of $76.15.

The Thursday morning market activity shows Murphy USA shares down by 2.0%, trading at $386.87. This implies a total value of $1,273,952 for West's 4,100 shares.

Delving into Murphy USA's Background

Murphy USA operates more than 1,700 fueling stations and convenience stores primarily across the Midwest and Southeastern United States. The firm owns about 75% of its locations, with most stores situated in high-traffic areas near Walmart supercenters. Murphy's stores typically range from 1,400-2,800 square feet, with most of its in-store sales derived from tobacco and nicotine products. The company acquired about 150 QuickChek stores in 2021, boosting its presence in grocery and foodservice. Murphy generates about two thirds of its profit from fuel retailing, with the remaining third coming from in-store sales.

Financial Milestones: Murphy USA's Journey

Revenue Growth: Murphy USA's revenue growth over a period of 3 months has faced challenges. As of 30 June, 2025, the company experienced a revenue decline of approximately -8.19%. This indicates a decrease in the company's top-line earnings. When compared to others in the Consumer Discretionary sector, the company faces challenges, achieving a growth rate lower than the average among peers.

Profitability Metrics: Unlocking Value

• Gross Margin: The company issues a cost efficiency warning with a low gross margin of 12.23%, indicating potential difficulties in maintaining profitability compared to its peers.

• Earnings per Share (EPS): Murphy USA's EPS is significantly higher than the industry average. The company demonstrates a robust bottom-line performance with a current EPS of 7.44.

Debt Management: Murphy USA's debt-to-equity ratio is notably higher than the industry average. With a ratio of 4.01, the company relies more heavily on borrowed funds, indicating a higher level of financial risk.

Valuation Metrics:

• Price to Earnings (P/E) Ratio: With a lower-than-average P/E ratio of 16.42, the stock indicates an attractive valuation, potentially presenting a buying opportunity.

• Price to Sales (P/S) Ratio: The P/S ratio of 0.41 is lower than the industry average, implying a discounted valuation for Murphy USA's stock in relation to sales performance.

• EV/EBITDA Analysis (Enterprise Value to its Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation & Amortization): At 10.2, Murphy USA's EV/EBITDA ratio reflects a below-par valuation compared to industry averages signalling undervaluation

Market Capitalization Analysis: Below industry benchmarks, the company's market capitalization reflects a smaller scale relative to peers. This could be attributed to factors such as growth expectations or operational capacity.

Now trade stocks online commission free with Charles Schwab, a trusted and complete investment firm.

Why Pay Attention to Insider Transactions

Insider transactions contribute to decision-making but should be supplemented by a comprehensive investment analysis.

Considering the legal perspective, an "insider" is defined as any officer, director, or beneficial owner holding more than ten percent of a company's equity securities, according to Section 12 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. This includes executives in the c-suite and major hedge funds. These insiders are mandated to disclose their transactions through a Form 4 filing, to be submitted within two business days of the transaction.

Pointing towards optimism, a company insider's new purchase signals their positive anticipation for the stock to rise.

Nevertheless, insider sells may not necessarily indicate a bearish view and can be influenced by various factors.

Cracking Transaction Codes

When it comes to transactions, investors tend to focus on those in the open market, detailed in Table I of the Form 4 filing. A P in Box 3 denotes a purchase, while S indicates a sale. Transaction code C signals the conversion of an option, and transaction code A denotes a grant, award, or other acquisition of securities from the company.

Check Out The Full List Of Murphy USA's Insider Trades.

Insider Buying Alert: Profit from C-Suite Moves

Benzinga Edge reveals every insider trade in real-time. Don't miss the next big stock move driven by insider confidence. Unlock this ultimate sentiment indicator now. Click here for access.

This article was generated by Benzinga's automated content engine and reviewed by an editor.