Benzinga

España
Italia
대한민국
日本
Français
Benzinga Edge
Benzinga Research
Benzinga Pro

  • Get Benzinga Pro
  • Data & APIs
  • Events
  • Premarket
  • Advertise
Contribute
España
Italia
대한민국
日本
Français

Benzinga

  • Premium Services
  • Financial News
    Latest
    Earnings
    Guidance
    Dividends
    M&A
    Buybacks
    Interviews
    Management
    Offerings
    IPOs
    Insider Trades
    Biotech/FDA
    Politics
    Healthcare
    Small-Cap
  • Markets
    Pre-Market
    After Hours
    Movers
    ETFs
    Options
    Cryptocurrency
    Commodities
    Bonds
    Futures
    Mining
    Real Estate
    Volatility
  • Ratings
    Analyst Color
    Downgrades
    Upgrades
    Initiations
    Price Target
  • Investing Ideas
    Trade Ideas
    Long Ideas
    Short Ideas
    Technicals
    Analyst Ratings
    Analyst Color
    Latest Rumors
    Whisper Index
    Stock of the Day
    Best Stocks & ETFs
    Best Penny Stocks
    Best S&P 500 ETFs
    Best Swing Trade Stocks
    Best Blue Chip Stocks
    Best High-Volume Penny Stocks
    Best Small Cap ETFs
    Best Stocks to Day Trade
    Best REITs
  • Money
    Investing
    Cryptocurrency
    Mortgage
    Insurance
    Yield
    Personal Finance
    Forex
    Startup Investing
    Real Estate Investing
    Prop Trading
    Credit Cards
    Stock Brokers
Research
My Stocks
Tools
Free Benzinga Pro Trial
Calendars
Analyst Ratings Calendar
Conference Call Calendar
Dividend Calendar
Earnings Calendar
Economic Calendar
FDA Calendar
Guidance Calendar
IPO Calendar
M&A Calendar
Unusual Options Activity Calendar
SPAC Calendar
Stock Split Calendar
Trade Ideas
Free Stock Reports
Insider Trades
Trade Idea Feed
Analyst Ratings
Unusual Options Activity
Heatmaps
Free Newsletter
Government Trades
Perfect Stock Portfolio
Easy Income Portfolio
Short Interest
Most Shorted
Largest Increase
Largest Decrease
Calculators
Margin Calculator
Forex Profit Calculator
100x Options Profit Calculator
Screeners
Stock Screener
Top Momentum Stocks
Top Quality Stocks
Top Value Stocks
Top Growth Stocks
Compare Best Stocks
Best Momentum Stocks
Best Quality Stocks
Best Value Stocks
Best Growth Stocks
Connect With Us
facebookinstagramlinkedintwitteryoutubeblueskymastodon
About Benzinga
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
Market Resources
  • Advanced Stock Screener Tools
  • Options Trading Chain Analysis
  • Comprehensive Earnings Calendar
  • Dividend Investor Calendar and Alerts
  • Economic Calendar and Market Events
  • IPO Calendar and New Listings
  • Market Outlook and Analysis
  • Wall Street Analyst Ratings and Targets
Trading Tools & Education
  • Benzinga Pro Trading Platform
  • Options Trading Strategies and News
  • Stock Market Trading Ideas and Analysis
  • Technical Analysis Charts and Indicators
  • Fundamental Analysis and Valuation
  • Day Trading Guides and Strategies
  • Live Investors Events
  • Pre market Stock Analysis and News
  • Cryptocurrency Market Analysis and News
Ring the Bell

A newsletter built for market enthusiasts by market enthusiasts. Top stories, top movers, and trade ideas delivered to your inbox every weekday before and after the market closes.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Data/Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Service Status
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Benzinga | All Rights Reserved
July 12, 2012 8:40 AM 5 min read

Carl Icahn Issues Letter To Non-Management Members Of The Forest Laboratories Board Of Directors

by Eddie Staley Benzinga Editor
Follow
Carl Icahn today issued the following letter to the non-management members of the Board of Directors of Forest Laboratories, Inc (NYSE:
FRX
). To the Non-Management Members of the Forest Labs Board: I am appealing to you directly because to date my overtures to Howard Solomon have fallen on deaf ears. I am concerned that we are reaching a precipice in this proxy contest from which an amicable solution is no longer possible. And while I believe I will prevail in this proxy contest, the one thing that Howard Solomon and I do agree on, is that we both believe that an amicable solution would best serve all shareholders and would avoid a great deal of distraction and expenses for the company. Perhaps you were not informed by Howard Solomon (although he stated otherwise) that before putting together a slate I sought to avoid a proxy contest by having you add Eric Ende and Daniel Ninivaggi to the Board, both very well qualified individuals. After Howard summarily rejected this request, I expressed a willingness to add those two individuals to the Board without removing any of the current Board members. Yet again, Howard flatly refused claiming that such shareholder representation on the Board would be a "distraction." His most recent statement to me was that the dismissal of my request was the will of the Board. If you are true in your belief that a prolonged proxy contest would be deleterious to Forest (as I am), how can you be so hastily dismissive? I strongly believe that any properly functioning board with the best interests of shareholders in mind would have quickly sought peace on the terms I outlined above for three simple reasons. First, as you know, we are your second largest shareholder, owning nearly $1 billion, or 10%, of the Forest Labs stock. As a large and concerned shareholder, we believe that we are entitled to representation on the Board and would improve the composition and functionality of the Board by bringing an owner's perspective to the Board. Second, Forest Labs is at a critical crossroads. The Board has allowed management to make strategic decisions that have resulted in an over dependence on two drugs that are either off or soon to be off patent and I doubt, along with many analysts, that the current pipeline will be sufficient to pick up the slack. The fact of the matter is that Forest Lab's enterprise value has declined by nearly $8 billion, or 55%, during the last 10 years and your own estimates call for an 80% decline in earnings in the current fiscal year. I cannot imagine how things will not get markedly worse when Namenda comes off patent in 2015. And the recent missteps in both underestimating the effects of the Lexapro patent cliff (which has been looming for years) and missing guidance on the recent launches of Teflaro and Daliresp merely strengthen my conviction that Forest is a company in dire need of help. Business as usual is no longer adequate. Third, I have a proven track record of nominating directors to companies that significantly outperform once those nominees are on the board, including specific instances of success in bio-pharma companies. The share prices of Amylin, Biogen, Genzyme, and Imclone have increased by approximately 174%, 180%, 48%, and 132%, respectively, since the dates my representatives joined (or announced joining) those boards, meaningfully outperforming the biotech index. I believe it is without question that my candidates have superior qualifications, would be productive members of the Forest Labs' Board, and would be a strong force in replicating the stellar results that my nominees have helped to produce in the companies mentioned above. I believe that Howard has been so dismissive of my request because he has his own agenda. However, given the stark lack of shareholder representation on the Board, the dire need for better strategic direction at the company and my track record with bio-pharma companies, I cannot fathom any legitimate reasons why you would dismiss my request so offhandedly. It is very reasonable for a shareholder of my size and with my track record to ask to nominate two persons to a board – one internal and one independent – without seeking the removal of any incumbent directors. Moreover, in my opinion, the notion that my nominees would be a distraction is a totally unfounded excuse. In fact, in many instances, my nominees were invited back on boards even after I was no longer active in the company. IF YOU GRANT ME THIS REPRESENTATION ON THE BOARD, WE CAN QUICKLY AVERT THE CONTINUATION OF A PROLONGED AND CONTENTIOUS PROXY FIGHT AND I AM SURE WE ALL AGREE THAT SUCH A FIGHT WOULD BE EXTREMLEY HARMFUL TO THE COMPANY GIVEN ITS CURRENT CONDITION. I urge you not to be blinded by ill-placed loyalty to Howard Solomon. Howard Solomon continues to assert that all is well at the company, assertions he has been making for the past 10 years as the enterprise value of the company continues its tumble. As I am sure you are aware, each of you owes a fiduciary duty of loyalty and duty of care to the Company and its stockholders. You owe no such duties to Mr. Solomon personally-- None. I know several of you have known Howard Solomon for many, many years. Do not let your personal relationship with Howard Solomon get in the way of what is right for the company and what your fiduciary duties require you to do. Time is running short. I hope to hear from you within the next few days.
Market News and Data brought to you by Benzinga APIs

© 2026 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.


Posted In:
NewsManagement
Beat the Market With Our Free Pre-Market Newsletter
Enter your email to get Benzinga's ultimate morning update: The PreMarket Activity Newsletter
Comments
Loading...