Choice Home Warranty Review

Read our Advertiser Disclosure.
Contributor, Benzinga
December 7, 2023
Choice Home Warranty
Overall Rating:
securely through Choice Home Warranty's website

While traditional home, landlord or rental property insurance covers things like the home dwelling and liability, a home warranty offers coverage for things like standard wear and tear to home appliances. Choice Home Warranty is a crowd-favorite provider of home warranties.

They’ll connect you with pre-screened local technicians with their 24 hours a day, 7 days a week home warranty service.

Choice Home Warranty’s plans offer coverage for appropriately maintained appliances no matter their age. The upgrade plan covers refrigerators and washing machines. Once you sign up, there is a 30 day waiting period before coverage begins. You’ll be protected for 365 days from the date your policy is active.

Best For
  • Coverage for normal wear and tear
  • 24/7 warranty service
  • Guarantees all repairs for 90 days, longer than the industry average
  • The upgrade plan covers refrigerators and washing machines
  • Charges a fee per service call

Choice Home Warranty Ratings at a Glance

Product Offering
Customer Pricing
User Benefits
User Experience

Choice Home Warranty Product Offering

Choice Home Warranty is a home warranty policy provider offering coverage throughout the United States. As is the case with other home warranty service providers, Choice’s policies provide affordable system and appliance repairs that are necessary because of normal everyday wear and tear. Home warranty policies fill in some of the gaps left by your homeowner’s insurance policy, which only provides reimbursement for items damaged because of a covered peril like a fire. Homeowners who purchase home warranty policies usually do so because they want to protect themselves against the high cost of repairing or replacing these systems.

Choice Home Warranty offers two protection plans, both of which cover different systems and appliances. Simply choose the home warranty plan that’s right for you.

Basic Plan

Choice Home Warranty’s Basic Plan covers a selection of both systems and appliances. While most home warranty service providers offer one plan for appliances and one for home systems, both of Choice’s plans include a mix of both essential home components. The following are covered under Choice’s Basic Plan.

  • Heating system
  • Electrical system
  • Plumbing system
  • Plumbing stoppages
  • Water heater
  • Whirlpool bathtub
  • Oven, range and stove
  • Cooktop
  • Dishwasher
  • Built-In microwave
  • Garbage disposal
  • Ductwork
  • Garage door opener
  • Ceiling and exhaust fans

Total Plan

If you’re looking for more inclusions on your home warranty policy, you might want to consider Choice’s Total Plan instead. The Total Plan includes everything covered under the Basic Plan plus coverage for the following home components:

  • Air conditioning system
  • Refrigerator
  • Clothing washer
  • Clothing dryer

Optional Add-Ons

You can add optional coverage for the following home components to either one of Choice Home Warranty’s plans.

  • Pool and spa
  • Central vacuum
  • Second refrigerator
  • Well pump
  • Limited roof leak coverage
  • Standalone freezer
  • Sump pump
  • Septic system
  • Septic tank pumping

Add-on coverages for your service contract are available for a few extra dollars per month and may come with their own service fee due when you receive a repair or replacement. 

Choice Home Warranty reserves the right to select a contractor to provide qualifying repairs and replacements under your policy. The company requires that you submit a claim before seeking services, and it will not reimburse you for any services you schedule without first consulting a Choice representative.

Choice states that it will begin contacting representatives within four hours of you filing your claim. Though the company states that it attempts to provide service on all claims within 48 hours, the sample contract available on Choice’s website states that “it could take more than 48 hours for a service provider to accept the request” after scheduling. This means that service is not guaranteed within 48 hours, a policy that some competing home warranty providers offer to ensure quick response times.

Choice Home Warranty does not cover known or unknown pre-existing conditions, which are problems that your household appliances or systems have before you sign up for your home warranty plan. Though the company does not have age limitations on the homes, systems and appliances it covers, all covered home components must be in good working condition at the time you sign up for coverage. Your coverage begins 30 days after signing onto your policy and lasts for the length of your contract term, typically 365 days. You must pay a $50 administrative fee if you cancel your policy before the term of the contract is complete.

Overall, Choice Home Warranty’s policies are straightforward and easy to understand. Policy inclusions and exclusions laid out in the company’s sample contract are standard and comparable to coverages you’ll find with other home warranty providers. Though Choice’s policies earn points for clearly defining coverage and offering two options for combination system and appliance warranty plans, it loses points for the terms of its service agreement and the possibility of lengthy repair times. 

Customer Service Rating [4 Stars]

Choice Home Warranty provides a few different methods you can use to file a claim or get in touch with the company’s customer service team, including:

  • Via phone: To contact Choice Home Warranty via phone, call 800-816-2688.
  • Though email: If you’d prefer to contact Choice Home Warranty by leaving a message, complete a contact request form through the company’s website here.

If you already have an appliance or system warranty through Choice, you can also contact a representative through your online customer portal. When you enroll in coverage, Choice will provide you with access to your portal, which you can use to file claims and connect with a customer service representative through chat and message. You can also file a claim by phone or through a contact request form if you prefer. 

Customer Pricing

Like auto insurance, health insurance and any other type of home protection you might have, Choice Home Warranty requires you to pay a premium each month to maintain your coverage. Choice does not provide pricing information on its website — instead, you’ll need to submit your personal information and property details to view pricing info. This can be a cumbersome process, especially for homeowners in the early stages, but this home warranty company does offer quality perks that can be helpful. Weigh the pricing issue against the home warranty benefits you receive.

To help you get a better idea of what you might pay for your home warranty, Benzinga requested a few sample quotes from Choice Home Warranty in multiple states where the company operates. The table below summarizes the pricing information received.

StateBasic PlanTotal Plan
Pennsylvania$46.67 per month$55 per month
California$46.67 per month$55 per month
Texas$46.67 per month$55 per month

As you can see, location does not seem to make an obvious difference in the basic price of each policy before adding optional coverages. One area where Choice Home Warranty can improve its transparency is by listing basic monthly policy prices on its website without requiring the user to consent to contact by a salesperson. Pricing for Choice’s plans vary from around $560 to $660 annually for coverage, which is more expensive than most other home warranty companies.

In addition to your premium, home warranty contracts also come with service fees. Your service fee is the amount of money you pay to the contractor who completes your repair or replacement when you receive it. A home warranty service fee is not the same thing as a deductible — your service fee is due every time you use your policy benefits. Unlike a deductible, you don’t “reach” your service fee.

Choice Home Warranty’s policies all include an $85 per-incident service fee. This is higher than the industry average, which is around $75. While this $10 difference might not seem like a major deal to most homeowners, you may want to take this increased cost into consideration if you think you might use your benefits often (for example, if you live in an older home). 

As is the case with most home warranty policies, Choice Home Warranty also institutes limitations on the total amount it will pay out each year for covered problems. Once you hit your limit, Choice will not cover any future repairs or replacements, regardless of whether the problem you’re experiencing is covered under your policy. Choice’s aggregate policy limit is $3,000 for most covered home components included with each plan. This is exceptionally higher than other home warranty companies, which provides additional value to your policy. Limitations on optional systems and appliances vary depending on the damaged component.

User Benefits

Choosing a home warranty policy can be difficult. The following are a few stand-out benefits that come with choosing a home warranty policy from Choice Home Warranty.

  • Straightforward contracts: Much of homeowners’ frustration with home warranty policies is a lack of coverage and inclusions. There’s nothing worse than purchasing a home warranty policy, paying your premiums each month and discovering that the repair you need isn’t covered because of what’s in your policy’s fine print.

Choice Home Warranty’s sample contract is simple, straightforward and easier to navigate than most of its competitors. This warranty protection does not include long lists of excluded components on most covered home systems and appliances, which further extends the usefulness of your coverage.

  • High coverage limits: Some home warranty companies put low coverage caps on their policies to avoid paying for the full cost of covered repairs and replacements. Choice Home Warranty includes a $3,000 coverage limit for most of the items included on its Basic and Total plans, which is more than enough to cover most incidents residential property owners might run into.
  • 24/7 claims reporting: Choice Home Warranty provides 24/7 claims reporting, and the company will begin searching for a technician within four hours of the time that you file your claim. While most home warranty companies include a provision that states that they’ll try to get to your repair within 48 hours, few companies encode the scheduling process within their contracts like Choice does. 

User Experience

Choice Home Warranty provides an exceptionally easy user experience, no matter if you’re buying a policy or filing a claim. Getting signed onto a policy takes only a few minutes and can be done entirely online. You’ll also be able to browse a sample contract before signing up for coverage, which can be beneficial if you’re actively comparing policies.

Filing a claim is also simple. You can file a claim and upload documentation directly through your customer portal or you can contact a representative for assistance. With multiple contact methods and options for submitting a quote at any hour, Choice makes it easier to use your benefits.  

Whether you are a homebuyer or seller, you can use these plans to protect properties where you have a vested interest. The same can be said for real estate professionals.

Choice Home Warranty Versus Competitors

With so many home warranty policies available, choosing the right one often comes down to research. Companies like Amazon Home Warranty, Sears Home Warranty and Cinch Home Services also offer home warranty policies comparable to Choice. However, each company sets its own contract terms and decides what is and is not covered by your policy.

Benzinga offers insights and reviews on the following home warranty providers. If you found this review helpful, consider expanding your search for the best home protection policy using a few of the links below.   


Choice Home Warranty can be a strong choice for your home protection plan — particularly if you’re concerned about being denied coverage because of the cost of your repairs. While some home warranty companies might limit repair payouts to as little as $500 for major appliances and systems, Choice includes $3,000 worth of coverage for most major home components. Both of its plans include both system and appliance coverage, and all repairs provided include 30-day guarantees on service. Though plans are more costly when compared to the rest of the home warranty industry, these higher maximums could make Choice Home Warranty worth the extra expense.    

Frequently Asked Questions


Who needs home warranty coverage?


Home warranty coverage can be beneficial for home buyers, home sellers or even real estate agents, depending on the situation.


How do you protect against repair costs at home?


Home insurance can cover certain issues in your home, but it does not cover basic repairs. You can use a home warranty to handle basic repairs. Just make sure to check your policy for exclusions that may be problematic.


What is the best home warranty?


The best home warranty balances pricing with coverage. Remember that your home warranty provider will charge a per-service fee, but they might also provide discounts for certain types of repairs. Review your plan carefully so you know what you should get for your money.

Submit Your One Minute Opinion

How do you like Choice Home Warranty?

About Sarah Horvath

Sarah is an expert in the insurance, investing for retirement and cryptocurrency space.