PropThink: Dendreon Q3 Earnings Preview: Can the Company Overcome the Odds?
By Ivan Deryugin
One of the most controversial companies in the biotechnology sector today is Dendreon (NASDAQ: DNDN). To some, the company represents the worst of Wall Street, an overhyped company with an overhyped product that has cost investors huge sums of wealth. And to others, Dendreon is a company that is deeply misunderstood, and whose true value has yet to be realized. Since the company went public over a decade ago, its stock has been a battlefield between these two opposing forces.
Dendreon's stock soared from 2009 to 2011 as optimism regarding Provenge, the company's unique prostate cancer therapy, grew. And the stock fell sharply as that optimism proved to be excessive. Dendreon has failed to ramp up sales of Provenge in a meaningful way, and the results of that can be seen in the stock's chart, shown above. But, with shares hovering near $4, has the pessimism surrounding Dendreon become too much? With over 30% of the company's float sold short, the situation is ripe for a short squeeze. And with the company set to report Q3 2012 earnings on October 30, there may be an opportunity for traders to profit.
Setting the Stage
If an investor were to look at Dendreon's results for Q2 2012, and they had never heard of the company, they would be likely to assume that the company is on the right path. After all, sales of Provenge came in at $79.964 million, up 66.11% from a year ago. And the company's net loss narrowed to 65 cents per share, down from 79 cents a year ago. But, if that investor were to look at expectations for Provenge when it was launched, they would likely be disappointed. For fiscal 2012, the current consensus forecast calls for Dendreon to post a loss of $2.64 per share.
While that may not be outrageous for a biotechnology company in the process of launching a new product, Dendreon was expected to be posting solid profits by now back when Provenge was first launched. Earnings forecasts for Dendreon had called for earnings of almost $2 per share for fiscal 2012 back in 2010, and they have been steadily declining ever since.
As Medivation (NASDAQ: MDVN) and Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ) have launched their own prostate cancer therapies, Xtandi and Zytiga, many investors see them as being the death knell of Dendreon. However, it may be too early to write the company off. CEO John Johnson is working hard to turn the company around, and the company's Q3 results will allow him and his team to update investors on their restructuring efforts, and where Provenge stands in the market.
Q3 Earnings: Things to Watch For
The Reuters consensus forecast is for Dendreon to post a loss of 86 cents per share in Q3. And while the headline numbers (both for EPS and sales of Provenge) are important, they are not what investors need to be focused on. Right or wrong, Dendreon faces a large amount of doubt regarding its ability to survive as a standalone company, and the company needs to disprove such doubts on its Q3 conference call. Specifically, there are 4 issues that need to be addressed:
1. Sales force turnover: On its Q2 call, Dendreon admitted that increasing turnover in its sales force had negatively affected results. CEO John Johnson stated that sales in markets where there was significant turnover saw sales drop 30% sequentially relative to markets without such turnover issues. He stated that there should be stabilization in the third quarter, and he should provide an update on this issue when Q3 earnings are released. Credit Suisse (which has a neutral rating and $6 price target on the stock) says that thisissue is fixable, but that the "window is closing." Because of the complex logistics of infusing Dendreon, the firm believes that physicians need more assistance from Dendreon than they would if it was a simpler drug, and that if the company is unable to fix the issues within its sales force, that physicians may simply move on from choosing to utilize the drug.With Xtandi now approved, and Bayer set to file for approval of its own prostate cancer drug by the end of 2012, there may be increased "poaching" of Dendreon sales representatives, an issue that the company needs to prevent.
2. Competition: Perhaps the biggest issue facing Dendreon is the assumption that Provenge is inferior to other prostate cancer therapies. Analysts put pressure on Dendreon's executives on its Q2 conference call to discuss the impact that Zytiga had on the quarter's results, and now that Xtandi is approved, and with Zytiga's PDUFA date for pre-chemotherapy use of December 15 fast approaching, this pressure is likely to intensify. Dendreon, from CEO John Johnson on down, needs to unequivocally reiterate its view that Dendreon is a complimentary therapy, and that these new prostate cancer drugs are not competitors, but rather partners in the goal of fighting prostate cancer. Joe DePinto, Dendreon's head of commercial operations, stated this multiple times on the company's last conference call:
"We see this product [Zytiga] as complementary, we see them to be used as more and more therapies come out in this space. Patients will be able to have the benefit of multiple therapeutic options and we see the importance of the sequencing and what's occurring in sequencing out in the market both at the podium, at major meetings, as well as what we are hearing when we talk to physicians as being an important component. We also believe that in that sequencing story Provenge as an immunotherapy should be sequenced up front prior to Zytiga. We are also seeing in the marketplace is that as competitors or additional products enter this space, the noise increases, more patients get screened and this is better for patients and also better for us, because those are the patients that are identified earlier at asymptomatic patients that would be ideal to start on Provenge therapy."
As more men receive screenings for prostate cancer, thanks to increased awareness, more cases can be caught early, the ideal time for Provenge to be used. Dendreon needs to make this point clear, and also tell both analysts and investors that the physicians using Provenge are using it in conjunction with other therapies. Aetna (NYSE: AET) recently expanded coverage, citing the medical necessity of Provenge in patients where their prostate cancer has spread, but not yet reached the liver. CEO John Johnson also stated that Zytiga did not take share from Provenge in the pre-chemotherapy market, and that the issues the company saw in Q2 were internal in nature, and therefore fixable. Continue reading by clicking here.
PropThink is an intelligence service that delivers long and short trading ideas to investors in the healthcare and life sciences sectors. Our focus is on identifying and analyzing technically-complicated companies and equities that are grossly over or under-valued. We offer daily market coverage, weekly feature stories, and a newsletter to investors who subscribe on PropThink.com. To learn more, follow us on Twitter or visit us at http://www.propthink.com.
You should assume that as of the publication date of any report or letter, PropThink, LLC and persons or entities with whom it has relation ships (collectively referred to as "PropThink") has a position in all stocks (and/or options of the stock) covered herein that is consistent with the position set forth in our research report. Following publication of any report or letter, PropThink intends to continue transacting in the securities covered herein, and we may be long, short, or neutral at any time hereafter regardless of our initial recommendation. To the best of our knowledge and belief, all information contained herein is accurate and reliable, and has been obtained from public sources we believe to be accurate and reliable, and not from company insiders or persons who have a relationship with company insiders. PropThink was not compensated to publish this article. Our full disclaimer is available at http://www.propthink.com/disclaimer.
The owner of this announcement warrants that:
(i) the releases contained herein are protected by copyright and other applicable laws; and
(ii) they are solely responsible for the content, accuracy and originality of the
information contained therein.
Source: PropThink via Thomson Reuters ONE