Rent-A-Center Inc RCII agreed to sell itself to Vintage Capital Management at $15 per share, which has some investors questioning why the stock is trading at an approximate 70-cent discount to the purchase price. Loop Capital Markets took a dive into the stock's potential merger arbitrage opportunity.
The Analyst
Loop Capital Markets' Anthony Chukumba maintained a Hold rating on Rent-A-Center's stock with an unchanged $15 price target.
The Thesis
Immediately following Rent-A-Center's initial acquisition announcement in June, the stock was trading within 1 percent of the $15 per share offer, Chukumba said in a Tuesday note. (See his track record here.)
At that time, the narrow spread suggested investors were confident in the deal closing despite a lack of financing contingency from Vintage Capital, the analyst said. Yet the spread between Rent-A-Center's price and the takeout offer has notably expanded over the past few weeks after the Federal Trade Commission sent a second information request, he said.
The FTC's second request for information shouldn't come as a surprise, as Vintage Capital already owns a competing rent-to-own business, Buddy's Home Furnishing, Chukumba said. Most rent-to-own customers fall within lower income brackets and/or poor credit scores, while the industry as a whole has a poor historical consumer protection track record, he said.
Vintage Capital "has a lot of incentive" to complete the acquisition of Rent-A-Center, a retailer whose turnaround strategy is progressing at a better-than-expected rate, in the analyst's view. Vintage Capital will likely be "highly amenable" to any potential FTC requests or remedies, including significant store divestitures, Chukumba said.
Under a scenario where the transaction is not completed, the downside to Rent-A-Center's stock is relatively limited, and after an initial investor shock, shares should trade around the $13 to $14 level, according to Loop Capital Markets.
Price Action
Rent-A-Center shares were trading nearly flat at $14.29 at the time of publication Tuesday.
Related Links:
Why Stifel Says Rent-a-Center May Go For $10.50 Per Share In A Sale
Rent-A-Center Receives A Bid From A Familiar Source
Photo by Jeff Bedford/Wikimedia.
© 2024 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.
Comments
Trade confidently with insights and alerts from analyst ratings, free reports and breaking news that affects the stocks you care about.