reports hero background
Updated: Sep 27, 2026
AII Logo

American Integrity

NYSE:AII·Stock Analysis Report
Day Range
$25.74 - $26.13
Market Cap
493.56M
P/E Ratio
5.9882
Avg Value
$21.60
Year Range
$16.19 - $27.00
$26.06$0.22 (0.85%)
1
General Information
American Integrity Insurance Group Inc is engaged in the property and casualty insurance business. It provides personal residential property insurance for single-family homeowners and condominium owners as well as coverage for vacant dwellings and investment properties, predominantly in Florida.

The Company's property and casualty insurance is currently offered in Florida, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia.

2
American Integrity (AII) Stock Graph
3
How We Grade American Integrity (AII)

We grade stocks based on past performance, their future growth potential, intrinsic value, dividend history, and overall financial health.

The chart below shows how we grade American Integrity (AII) across the board compared to its closest peers.

4
Benzinga Edge Rankings

Benzinga Edge stock rankings give you four critical scores to help you identify the strongest and weakest stocks to buy and sell.

Momentum measures a stock's relative strength based on its price movement patterns and volatility over multiple timeframes, ranked as a percentile against other stocks.

Stock Score Locked: Want to See it?
Benzinga Rankings give you vital metrics on any stock – anytime.
5
Peer Ratings

See how American Integrity compares to its peers in these key performance metrics from Benzinga Rankings.

Top Peers
Value
Quality
Growth
Momentum
Short
Medium
Long
AMSFAMERISAFE
N/A
7.23
17.42
4.11
ITICInvestors Title
N/A
49.81
54.58
75.25
ACICAmerican Coastal
96.04
N/A
23.61
10.81
GBLIGlobal Indemnity Group
N/A
N/A
40.32
21.97
Short: price trend over the last couple of months
Medium: price trend over the last couple of quarters
Long: price trend over the past year
Stock Score Locked: Want to See it?
Benzinga Rankings give you vital metrics on any stock – anytime.
6
Future Growth
Our estimate of future price growth is based on an aggregation of 3 analyst ratings over the past 3 months and their 12-month price targets.

Below, you can see that analysts are estimating a 12-month price target range of $23.00 - $26.00 with an average of $25.00

-0.75%
Expected movement for American Integrity (AII) over the next 12 months
Based on these rankings

Recent Ratings for American Integrity (AII)

Piper Sandler
Date:
Aug 13, 2026
Action:
Maintains
Prev. Target:
$23.00
New Target:
$26.00
Citizens
Date:
Aug 12, 2026
Action:
Maintains
Prev. Target:
$25.00
New Target:
$26.00
Piper Sandler
Date:
Jul 15, 2026
Action:
Maintains
Prev. Target:
$20.00
New Target:
$23.00
7
Past Performance
How has American Integrity (AII) performed over the past 5 years?

The two main factors that we consider when analyzing past performance is overall return and volatility

Using these two metrics, we can determine if this stock gave its investors enough return for the risk that they took on by owning it. This is measured by the sharpe ratio, which has been used as a primary measure of risk/reward trade-off for almost 60 years.

This ratio can be interpreted as the amount of return an investor has received for the amount of risk that they took on by owning the stock over that timeframe.

American Integrity (AII) sharpe ratio over the past 5 years is 0.4934 which is considered to be above average compared to the peer average of -0.0464