Login

New to Benzinga?

Register

Already have an account?

TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood

One of the first and important online trading decisions you’ll ever need to make is which online brokerage is best for you. Use the services of a suitable broker, and you’ll build success as an investor.

TD Ameritrade and Robinhood are similar, yet vastly different, so stick with us so we can help you make an informed choice.

TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: Overview

Commissions

$6.95

Best For
  • Beginner investors
  • Advanced traders
  • Investors who want portfolio-building advice.
Commissions

Free

Best For
  • Low cost stock trading
  • Beginners looking to start trading
  • Investors on the go

Who’s TD Ameritrade For?

TD Ameritrade is a trading solution for all types of security traders. Despite the advanced features it offers, it is a good fit for beginners, too.

TD Ameritrade’s portfolio advice solutions make it suitable for investors that seek ready-to-go portfolios. It supports a wide variety of trading instruments, so if you like the idea of having hundreds of diversified options at your fingertips, you’ll be right at home.

Read Benzinga’s full TD Ameritrade Review

Who’s Robinhood For?

Robinhood is a broker for beginner stock and cryptocurrency traders based in the U.S. Robinhood’s platform is very limited, so if you’re not familiar with charting and indicators, then Robinhood will suit you well.

Robinhood’s platform makes the complex simple and allows you to trade on the go. If you are an advanced trader, you’ll likely struggle with Robinhood’s limitations.

Read Benzinga’s full Robinhood Review

TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: Platform and Tools

What TD Ameritrade Offers

TD Ameritrade offers three comprehensive trading solutions:

  • Web platform
  • Thinkorswim
  • Mobile platform
  • Source: https://www.tdameritrade.com

    1. Web Platform

    The web platform is suitable for traders of any level. It gives you access to a variety of informative and educational resources. Other useful features include alerts, screeners and a fully customizable platform.

    2. Thinkorswim

    Thinkorswim is the professional way to trade. It is a high-rank platform for serious investors. It includes high-level analysis tools and strategy testers. Thinkorswim can generate trading ideas and lets you balance risk.

    3. Mobile Platform

    The mobile solution, which works for smartphones and tablets, is basic, as its idea is to monitor trades and to look for opportunities. Recently, TD Ameritrade launched a solution for Apple Watch.

    What Robinhood Offers

    Robinhood offers a friendly interface, so anyone can jump in and start trading right away. Robinhood supports web-based, desktop, and mobile platforms. Compared to TD Ameritrade, its platform is basic and limited. It supports only the basic market orders, which is good since Robinhood’s goal is to provide a simple beginner platform.

    Source: https://robinhood.com/

    Bottom Line

    Robinhood is the right choice for you’re a beginner and you simply want to open and close trades. If you are looking for more options than this, TD Ameritrade will be the right choice for you.

TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: Research

What TD Ameritrade Offers

TD Ameritrade offers a rich set of research and educational tools. Its website contains special sections on:

  • Education
  • Guidance
  • Retirement
  • Research

Its platforms also have a rich set of market research tools. Some of these include:

  • 400,000+ economic indicators from the FED
  • Information from top third-party sources
  • Visual heat maps showing the hottest assets
  • Live streams with breaking news from sources like CNBC
  • Social media market sentiments

 

Source: https://www.tdameritrade.com

What Robinhood Offers

Robinhood does offer research tools. Few of them are:

  • Analyst ratings: trading ratings from analysts on Wall Street
  • People also bought: what other investors on Robinhood are trading
  • About section: information about the company you are trading

This is part of Robinhood’s plan to keep the app basic and simple. If you need more than this, you’ll need to find external sources for your research.

Bottom Line

TD Ameritrade offers a rich database of research tools. Although Robinhood offers market research it is very basic and limited compared to TD.

TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: Commission and Fees

TD Ameritrade’s Fees

Our TD Ameritrade review identifies slightly higher fees, but its commission plans are transparent.

  • Stocks
    • Internet: $6.95
    • Interactive Voice Response (IVR) Phone System: $34.99
    • Broker-assisted: $44.99
  • ETFs
    • Commission-free ETFs:No commission
    • Internet: $6.95
    • Interactive voice response (IVR) Phone System: $34.99
    • Broker-assisted: $44.99
  • Mutual funds
    • No transaction fee (NTF): No commission
    • No-load: $49.99
    • Load: No commission
  • Options
    • Internet: $6.95 + $0.75 fee per contract
    • Options exercises and assignments: $19.99
    • Interactive voice response (IVR) phone system: $34.99 + $0.75 fee per contract
    • Broker-assisted: $44.99 + $0.75 fee per contract
  • Fixed income
    • Bonds
      • Treasuries at auction: Available commission free
      • All other bonds and CMOs: On a net yield basis
    • CDs
      • New issue: On a yield basis
      • Secondary: On a yield basis
    • UITs
      • New issue: Placement fee from the issuer
      • Secondary: Placement fee from the issuer
  • Futures: $2.25 fee per contract (plus exchange and regulatory fees)
  • Forex
    • Non-commission: Based on the spread from the liquidity provider
    • Commission: $0.10 per 1,000 units with max charge of $1

Robinhood’s Fees

The fees are the cornerstone topic of every Robinhood review. This is where comes the power of Robinhood vs. TD Ameritrade. Robinhood’s trading solution is absolutely free, and this is what it means:

  • No commissions
  • No spreads
  • No platform fees
  • No other costs

You deposit your money and you are ready to trade for free.

Source: https://robinhood.com/

Robinhood sells a premium membership for $6 per month, Robinhood Gold. In exchange, Robinhood lets you trade on margin, effectively doubling your buying power. This feature is optional and you can still trade commission-free if you decide not to get it.

Bottom Line

This is another field where the two platforms differ. TD Ameritrade might be a bit costly, while Robinhood is totally free. TD Ameritrade offers a wide range of products and services in exchange for your charges. Robinhood is basic with no additional features and costs nothing.

Security

What TD Ameritrade Offers

TD Ameritrade is subject to strict U.S. regulatory requirements. The company is publicly listed on NASDAQ. The max leverage of 1:50 shows that TD Ameritrade takes its client’s money seriously. TD Ameritrade also stands behind a banking body, TD Bank, which offers more proof of reliability.

What Robinhood Offers

Robinhood is also subject to U.S. regulatory requirements. While not as big as TD Ameritrade, it conforms to the same financial rules. The company is not listed on a stock exchange and accepts only U.S. clients, which means that it conforms to the rules.

Bottom Line

Both companies abide by all United States regulatory bodies, so you’re in good, secure hands with both.

TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: Customer Support

What TD Ameritrade Offers

TD Ameritrade offers supportive licensed reps. You can get email support 24/7. Their phone support is available 24/5. You can also reach TD by live chat and fax.

TD is a big company with nearly 500 physical offices around the U.S. Their branches are all over the U.S. and can take all your inquiries.

What Robinhood Offers

Things work a little differently at Robinhood. You can still reach them via email or phone, but this might be tough. This is part of the “staying commission free” plan of the company. Everything is minimal including the support. Moreover, Robinhood is 100% internet based, meaning that they have no physical offices.

Bottom Line

TD Ameritrade is a company with a world-class support. Robinhood cannot compete with the licensed support reps of TD and their 500 offices all over the U.S.

TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: Tradable Asset Classes

What TD Ameritrade offers

TD Ameritrade offers a wide range of tradable assets, which include:

  • Stocks
  • Options
  • ETFs
  • Mutual funds
  • Futures
  • Forex
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Bonds
Source: https://www.tdameritrade.com

The variety of assets at TD Ameritrade guarantees you a diversified portfolio. Moreover, this provider offers ready-to-go managed portfolios built by true professionals.

What Robinhood offers

Robinhood is limited in terms of tradable assets:

  • Stocks
  • ETFs
  • Cryptocurrency

Portfolio building and management would be a challenge with Robinhood, if you’re looking for a more complex strategy. If you’re looking for the basics, you’re in good hands.

Bottom Line

TD Ameritrade is the winner in this competition, as it provides a large range of diverse, tradable assets that Robinhood (though intentionally) cannot match.

TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: Ease of Use

What TD Ameritrade Offers

TD Ameritrade supports three different platforms. Each of these contains many trading indicators and advanced services. This information is hard to assimilate at first, especially for beginners. Otherwise, when you get used to the interface, you’ll be able to trade with one click.

The Thinkorswim platform is a professional solution, designed for experienced traders. If you aren’t advanced, it’s going to be rough going. In this case, you should try the web-based platform.

What Robinhood offers

Robinhood’s platform offers an easy-to-use interface with a high-level user experience. It’s clean, simple, straightforward and user-friendly. It simply buys and sells assets for free and is a rockstar in its own special category.

Source: https://robinhood.com

Bottom Line

Robinhood’s platform is easier to use than TD Ameritrade’s platform because it’s limited, though that’s fully intentional. TD Ameritrade is comprehensive and rich on resources.

Final Thoughts

TD Ameritrade and Robinhood are on two different planets in terms of trading solutions. Although the two companies operate in the same field, they aren’t true competitors.

TD Ameritrade is a cutting edge trading solution with a rich set of trading resources. Robinhood is basic, limited, and simple. TD Ameritrade is a comprehensive solution with standard charges and fees and Robinhood is totally free.

Depending on what you’re looking for, it’s easy to choose one over the other. If you like simplicity, you’ll choose Robinhood. If you want all the options under the sun, go with TD Ameritrade.

Broker Best For Commissions Account Minimum Choose your platform
TD Ameritrade
  • Beginner investors
  • Advanced traders
  • Investors who want portfolio-building advice.
$6.95 $0
Get started securely through TD Ameritrade's website
1 Minute Review

This publicly listed discount broker, which is in existence for over four decades, is service-intensive, offering intuitive and powerful investment tools. Especially, with equity investing, a flat fee is charged, with the firm claiming that it charges no trade minimum, no data fees, and no platform fees. Though it is pricier than many other discount brokers, what tilts the scales in its favor is its well-rounded service offerings and the quality and value it offers its clients.

Pros
  • Superior technology
  • No account minimum balance
  • Excellent customer support
  • Premier data and news partnerships
Cons
  • Slightly higher commissions
  • Can be for more advanced users
Current Promotion

Trade commission–free for 90 days & get up to $2500

Robinhood
  • Low cost stock trading
  • Beginners looking to start trading
  • Investors on the go
Free $0
Get started securely through Robinhood's website
1 Minute Review

Robinhood is a free stock trading mobile app that serves both iOS and Android devices. They offer an easy to use interface and have excellent integrations to easily deposit money and begin investing.

Pros
  • Free trading for all stocks
  • Multiple integrations for banking deposits
  • No transfer out fees
Cons
  • Lacks research reports
  • Some features require premium paid upgrades
Current Promotion

Invite a friend and get a free stock

Compare Online Brokers
Broker Commission Account Min Get Started

$6.95 for fewer than 30 trades/quarter. $0 Learn More

Flat-fee pricing: $5 per trade, Per-share pricing: $0.006-$0.01 per share ($1 minimum per trade) based on trading volume, Unbundled pricing: $0.002-$0.01 per share ($0.50-$1 minimum) based on trading volume $5,000 for individual retirement accounts (IRAs) Learn More

$4.95 volume discount available $0 Learn More

Free $0 Learn More

$0.005 per share minimum $1 and maximum 0.5% of trade value; volume discount available $0 for cash account, or a margin account with $2,000 Learn More