Best Rental Property Insurance

Share to Linkedin Share to Twitter Share to Facebook Share to Print More
Benzinga Money is a reader-supported publication. We may earn a commission when you click on links in this article. Learn more.

We narrowed the field to 4 companies that ranked for the best renters insurance. We’ll go over what each policy covers, the premium you would expect to pay and whether you can add additional coverage to your policy.

Cheapest Renters Insurance:

Renters Insurance Coverage Explained

Most renters insurance policies include 3 types of coverage:

  • Personal property: Personal property coverage pays to repair or replace your personal belongings after a covered peril up to your coverage limit. You’ll get clothing, furniture, electronics and other types of personal items covered. Personal property coverage doesn’t include coverage for vehicles you own. You’ll need comprehensive car insurance for that.
  • Personal liability: Personal liability coverage pays for legal representation and court-ordered judgments if someone gets injured on your property up to your policy limit. Your personal liability insurance may also cover you if you accidentally break or damage someone else’s property in your home.
  • Additional living expenses: Let’s say your home gets damaged and you can’t live in it. Additional living expenses cover the costs of finding a new place to stay while your space gets repaired. It includes hotel bills, transportation expenses and bills for meals normally cooked at home.

Renters insurance policies can have limitations on the events in which they will provide coverage. Many renters policies exclude pets and vehicles from their coverage. Some policies will exclude certain types of preventable damage like bed bug infestations.

Exclusions and coverage limitations are two of the reasons why it’s so important to thoroughly read every clause in your insurance policy before you sign. You don’t want to find out you don’t have enough coverage after a fire decimates your apartment’s furniture or a thief makes off with your electronics. 

The Best Rental Property Insurance Companies

Based on the criteria above, we picked the best and most affordable renters insurance companies.

  • Easy to tailor coverage
  • Reasonable rates
  • Loyalty rewards
  • Coverage for significant other
  • Only offers renters insurance at present
  • Not available in all states

1. Toggle

Toggle’s rental insurance makes sense for everyone. Toggle gives you complete control every step of the way, from covering your stuff to having your back as you reach for the next rung on the financial ladder. Toggle makes renters insurance easier to understand and more flexible to keep up with your ever-changing life.

Right now, renters in the following states can get Toggle: Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Minnesota, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia and Wisconsin. The company plans to cover other states soon.

Get Toggle for the price of one latte per month today.

  • Discount for bundling
  • Access to vetted companies
  • Doesn’t directly offer home insurance
  • Mobile app doesn’t support home insurance

2. Progressive

Renters insurance policies from Progressive offer you comprehensive protection.

Under a Progressive policy, you get personal property coverage, liability coverage and also reimbursement for living expenses if your home or apartment is severely damaged.

You can easily understand policies from Progressive and its website makes it clear what is and isn’t included with your coverage.

Additional policy options include water damage and personal injury protection. The average cost of renters insurance from Progressive costs between $13 and $35 per month, which makes it an exceptionally affordable choice.

Progressive offers a great selection of policies available throughout the United States suitable for most renters’ budgets and needs. The insurance powerhouse also offers a wide range of discounts. Because Progressive offers over 30 insurance types, you’ll probably find some way to take advantage of its bundling discount.

You can also get a discount when you pay your policy in full, opt to receive documents via email or get a quote at least 3 days before you need it to go into effect.

  • Easy application that you can complete using the app
  • Fast, hassle-free claims process
  • Supports charities
  • Not available in all states
  • Customer service is only available using the app or website

3. Lemonade

Lemonade, an innovative and engaging new insurance provider, offers some of the most affordable policies on the market. The company uses a new peer-to-peer insurance model.

It works like this: At the beginning of the month, everyone signed onto Lemonade pays a premium. Over the course of the month, Lemonade takes money out of the “pot” to cover insurance claims and administrative costs.

Lemonade also takes a small percentage of money out every month to hold in reserve in case the next month’s claims override the amount of money brought in by premiums.

At the end of the month, anything left over gets donated to charity. It’s a unique model that does away with the incentive most insurance companies have to pay out as little as possible in claims to maximize profits.

Renters can get insurance for as little as $5 a month, making Lemonade by far one of the cheapest ways for renters to protect themselves. Lemonade earned a Financial Stability Rating of A-Exceptional from Demotech Inc. Though you can only get Lemonade in 19 states, the company’s model has rapidly expanded.

Get a quote from the app in as little as 90 seconds using an intuitive question-and-answer style format. You can get discounts for fire and burglar alarms. At the end of your signup, you receive a transparent policy summary that tells you exactly where your money goes.

Digital, socially responsible and exceptionally affordable, Lemonade offers a top renters insurance choice.

4. Allstate

Allstate provides a standard bundling discount and discounts for adding a burglar alarm, signing up for automatic bill pay, staying claims-free and reaching retirement age.

If you already have an auto insurance policy from Allstate, you can get coverage for as little as $4 a month, which makes its auto bundling discount the best choice for renters. You can also adjust your deductible to pay even less per month.

Allstate’s affordable policies include many types of coverage that some competitors consider add-ons. For example, Allstate renters insurance plans include reimbursement for living expenses and guest medical insurance as standard coverage.

Add-ons from Allstate include flood protection, personal umbrella policies that boost your coverage in the event of a lawsuit and even identity theft protection.

Get Renters Insurance Now

It’s difficult to say exactly what you can expect to pay for renters insurance because each individual coverage provider uses its own unique formula to determine your premium.

For example, some insurers like State Farm do not ask about the breed of your dog when calculating your premium, some insurers only forbid coverage if you have a certain breed of dog and other insurers will refuse to insure you altogether if you own one of their restricted breeds.

Other factors like credit score, where you live and your claims history also each play a unique factor in each company’s premium formula. Before you commit to an insurance provider, get as many quotes as possible to make sure you don’t overpay for coverage.

Life Coming at You Fast?

Toggle isn’t your everyday insurance company. In fact, it’s changed the renters insurance landscape. Case in point: You have complete control every step of the way. Toggle makes insurance easier to understand (and offers total flexibility!) and guess what? Toggle can even keep up with you and your crazy-busy, ever-changing life.