Market Overview

Everyone's Talking About ROLARR Heading Into Intuitive Surgical Earnings: Here's What It Means

Share:

Intuitive Surgical, Inc. (NASDAQ: ISRG) is scheduled to report its second quarter results after Tuesday's market close. Estimize is expecting the company to earn $4.05 per share (based on 38 estimates) on revenue of $570.82 million. This compares to the Wall Street consensus estimate looking for the company to earn $3.98 per share on revenue of $567.85 million.

BTIG: Investors Like To Focus On ROLARR, But What Is It?

In a report published late May, Sean Lavin of BTIG discussed why a ROLARR study may pressure share of Intuitive Surgical.

For starters, according Lavin, "ROLARR (Robotic vs. Laparoscopic Resection for Rectal Cancer) is a randomized trial comparing the MIS approaches to treating this disease. The primary endpoint is the rate of conversion to open surgery. Mortality, morbidities, costs and disease-free margins will also be reported over time. "

The study is ongoing with an estimated completion date of June 2018, according to clinicaltrials.gov.

Commenting on ROLARR, Lavin noted that the trial is receiving "significant" investor attention but will probably not reveal a lot of information as it is "very tough to call results" and the trial is not a "fair comparison."

"While some docs may be very experienced with a robot, some may not be," Lavin wrote. "In general, we believe the use of robotics results in fewer conversions to open surgery, fewer morbidities, shorter hospital stays and probably higher costs than laparoscopic surgery for colorectal cancer."

Lavin continued that he expects the most likely outcome from the study will show similar conversion rates, slightly better cancer-free margins for robotics, slightly higher complications with robotics in inexperienced hands and higher costs with robotics. The analyst concluded that this outcome implies that Intuitive Surgical offers a higher cost solution without better outcomes.

Evercore: Initial Results ‘Better Than Feared'

Vijay Kumar of Evercore ISI commented in a note in early June that results of the first randomized ROLARR study were released at the ASCRS conference in Boston. The analyst noted that early commentary from attendees suggested that the results were "strong in both arms with no notable statistical difference between lap and robot)."

Kumar said the results indicate a "major positive" for Intuitive Surgical given that 600,000 colorectal procedures are still performed "open." The results reaffirm the thesis that many of these "open" cases will be converted to a minimally invasive procedure using a robot over time.

Finally, the analyst suggested that the results offers "incremental confidence" that Intuitive Surgical will post high single digits to double digits top-line over the next few years.

Leerink: ROLARR Study A ‘Validation' Of Robotics

Richard Newitter of Leerink commented in a note in early June that based on discussions with doctors who were present at the ASCRS conference, the ROLARR's results were "better than feared" as non-inferiority shows robotics is not worse than lap, and that the study "should be viewed as a clinical validation of robotics in an area (rectal surgery) where docs generally have already come to accept robotics' role in hard-to-perform rectal cases."

Newitter further suggested that the study reinforces the case that rectal surgery represents an "important procedure volume growth driver" for Intuitive Surgical, especially among the toughest-to-perform cases which occur deep in the pelvis.

Morgan Stanley: Market Is Large, But Largely Reflected In Stock

David Lewis of Morgan Stanley commented in a note on July 6 that Intuitive Surgical's market opportunity is "large" but it is already reflected in the stock's valuation.

According to Lewis, the company could boost its revenue at a 7 percent plus compounded annual growth rate over the next 10 years. However, the company has the highest OM/GM ratio in the space even following recent softer top-line growth. The analyst added that investors may view this as temporary with consensus estimates assuming an operating margin above 38 percent by 2017.

Lewis said his estimates assume a margin expansion "to a lesser extent" than consensus, even with 30 to 50 basis points of annual pressure due to product mix and trade-in headwinds. As such, "structural margin pressures will drive earnings growth more inline with sales."

Finally, Lewis concluded that shares are trading at 26 times 2016 estimates (versus large cap peers at around 17 times) and represents a premium based on growth, but its earnings may not materially outpace its peers.

Latest Ratings for ISRG

DateFirmActionFromTo
May 2019MaintainsBuy
Apr 2019MaintainsBuyBuy
Apr 2019MaintainsBuyBuy

View More Analyst Ratings for ISRG
View the Latest Analyst Ratings

Posted-In: ASCRS Conference btig David Lewis EstimizeAnalyst Color Previews Analyst Ratings Trading Ideas

 

Related Articles (ISRG)

View Comments and Join the Discussion!

Latest Ratings

StockFirmActionPT
CAPRMaintains12.4
BCELInitiates Coverage On23.0
DNOWMaintains14.0
HLIOMaintains46.0
GDIMaintains33.0
View the Latest Analytics Ratings
Don't Miss Any Updates!
News Directly in Your Inbox
Subscribe to:
Benzinga Trading Daily
Get pre-market outlook, mid-day update and after-market roundup emails in your inbox.
Market in 5 Minutes
Everything you need to know about the market - quick & easy.
Daily Analyst Rating
A summary of each day’s top rating changes from sell-side analysts on the street.
Thank You

Thank you for subscribing! If you have any questions feel free to call us at 1-877-440-ZING or email us at vipaccounts@benzinga.com

S&P Capital IQ's Expectations For Apple's Q3 Earnings

Benchmark's Kurnos: It Wouldn't Shock Me If Amazon Bought Jet.com