On May 29, Oppenheimer & Co. (Opco) analysts Amit Nihalani and Steve Manaker published a report "Attractively Valued Growth Story…" and initiated coverage of $263 million cap Bluerock Residential Growth REIT BRG
Bluerock provides capital at a target 15 percent preferred return to fund the development of multi-family apt communities, with an option to purchase them at below market valuations.
The Bluerock strategy includes the ongoing sale of stabilized apartment communities, which can make it more difficult to project earnings on a quarterly basis vs. some of its industry peers.
That said, according to the company earnings release, during Q1 2015 Blackrock disposed of its investment in 23Hundred@BerryHill Nashville property for $61.2 million or $230,000 per unit, "…an IRR of 60%, and total return on capital of 282%."
Tale Of The Tape - Peers/Big Picture
On May 11, $282 million cap Independence Realty Trust IRT
announced the acquisition of $268 million cap Trade Street Residential TSRE
for cash and stock.
On May 26, Bluerock issued ~6.35 million common shares in a secondary offering at $13.00 per share, netting BRG ~$77.4 million.
Preferred Apartment Communities APTS
, with a similar market cap of $255 million, has outperformed its peer group during the past year. One unique aspect of Preferred Apartment approach is that its portfolio includes neighborhood shopping centers, and student housing along with its apartment assets.
Preferred also enters into forward purchase agreements for communities under development, where it provides bridge and mezzanine loans in conjunction with its purchase option.
Opco - BRG: Initiate Outperform, $16 PT
The Opco $16 target price represents a potential ~17.2 percent upside for BRG shares, based upon the previous close of $13.65 per share; for a total return of 25.7 percent, including the 8.5 percent dividend yield.
Opco based its BRG $16 PT on 13.3x its 2016 estimated AFFO of $1.20 per share. Notably, this AFFO multiple is a 41 percent discount compared to Opco's overall residential REIT sector, which includes many established larger cap names.
Additionally, Opco's FFO estimates are below consensus for both 2015 and 2016, and BRG shares are trading at a 14 percent discount to Opco's NAV estimate of $15.90, based on a 5.5 percent cap rate.
However, BRG intends to continue operating at higher leverage ratio than its peer group, (targeting ~65 percent); and utilizes a development model which inherently has more moving parts than simply owning and acquiring portfolios of stabilized communities.
Opco - BRG: Investment Thesis
Opco views Bluerock "as a growth REIT, buying assets by investing in complex real estate situations. The REIT typically invests in projects that have capital or operational issues.
BRG's investment process identifies which properties have good long-term potential and sees through the near-term issues. This allows BRG to purchase attractive assets at below-market rates."
The existing Bluerock portfolio is 94.1 percent occupied contains 4,131 apt units, (including 636 units of preferred equity), with average rent of $1,292.
Opco - BRG Dividend/Risks
Since its IPO in 2014, Bluerock has paid a monthly dividend of $0.0967 per share, equivalent to $0.29 per quarter, or $1.16 annually.
Opco believes that "the current dividend is safe," but does not anticipate that it will be increased in the near term.
Opco calculates that Bluerock "will pay out 137% of our estimated 2015 AFFO, and 96% of our 2016 estimates. These numbers assume no dividend growth over the next two years."
Opco - BRG Risk Factors
While BRG has significant exposure to Central Florida markets, Opco expects "the concentration will decline as the portfolio grows."
Opco also noted: broad and local economic slowdowns, increased supply due to new development, and rising interest rates as potential risks.
Opco - BRG Big Picture
"We believe the timing is right for BRG's strategy. Non-Gateway markets in the Southeast are experiencing above average job and population growth. The demand for quality apartments is increasing with absorption outpacing new developments. Multifamily fundamentals are strong with occupancy at full capacity and rental rates rising. We expect this trajectory to continue with the US economy steadily improving."