Market Overview

Yum Vs. Chipotle: What's Wall Street Saying?

Yum Vs. Chipotle: What's Wall Street Saying?
Related YUM
Take A Bite Out Of This Fast Food Guide To The Q3 Earnings Season
5 Biggest Price Target Changes For Wednesday
Related CMG
Whole Foods' Hepatitis A Outbreak And Other Past Food Scares
Comps Will Be In Focus As 3 Restaurant Stocks Prepare To Report Q3 Results
McNuggets, McPick 2, Breakfast Help McDonald's Beat Restaurant Slump (Investor's Business Daily)

Yum! Brands, Inc. (NYSE: YUM) rose and Chipotle Mexican Grill, Inc. (NYSE: CMG) fell in response to earnings, but the story of neither restaurant chain is lacking in ambiguity.

Both companies have much in common, besides casual dining.

'It's All About China'

WIth Yum, "it's all about China," where the company gets half its revenue, said Barclays' Jeffrey Bernstein, who maintained an Equal Weight rating on Yum but raised his target 3 percent to $82.

As for Chipotle, where recent earnings rose 50 percent, "the current level of growth isn't sustainable," he said. The analyst cut his price target 6 percent to $685, maintaining an Equal Weight rating.

Related Link: Chipotle's Sales Growth Not Meeting Expectations: A Technical Look

Yum gained 3 percent recently to $83.52; Chipotle traded down 6 percent to $650.50.

Same-Store Sales & Activism

Yum bulls are encouraged by its recent same-store sales improvements in China, while bears question whether operations there can fully recover as the novelty of pizza and fried chicken wears off, Bernstein said.

Cowen's Andrew M. Charles maintained a Market Perform rating and $81 target on Yum, while Stifel's Paul Westra rates the stock a Buy.

Westra, who maintains a $110 target on Yum, believes an activist-lead campaign will emerge later this year forcing the company to undertake a debt-financed buyback.

A food safety scare in China hit Yum last summer and has continued to haunt results. Same-store sales there continued to fall in the first quarter, but at a slower-than-expected rate.

"These results have bought the company some time," said Morgan Stanley's John Glass, who noted widening profit margins at the company's Asian operations.

Glass maintained an Equal Weight rating on Yum and called its first-quarter results "enough for now."

'Increased Digital Capabilities'

At Chipotle, Glass maintained an Overweight rating and $749 target, suggesting that despite an inevitable slowdown, the company's story still has legs on widening profit margins, mobile payments, home delivery and on-line catering.

Cowen's Andrew Charles, too, cited Chipotle's "increased digital capabilities" and a marketing campaign to sustain sales growth, and reiterated an Outperform rating and $775 target on the company.

But Wedbush's Nick Setyan maintained a Neutral rating on Chipotle and shaved 6 percent from his price target to $665.

Setyan noted that cheaper food costs and lower stock compensation for Chipotle executives were responsible for the company's first-quarter earnings beat.

Street estimates for Chipotle same-store sales growth are "poised to come down," Setyan said, adding that clarity on results from its increased marketing and menu changes won't materialize until later this year.

On Average

Wall Street analysts on average maintain a Hold rating and $81.84 target on Yum, while on Chipotle, analysts are Overweight with a $743.79 target.

Latest Ratings for YUM

Oct 2016Credit SuisseUpgradesNeutralOutperform
Oct 2016BarclaysMaintainsEqual-Weight
Oct 2016NomuraMaintainsBuy

View More Analyst Ratings for YUM
View the Latest Analyst Ratings

Posted-In: Wall Street Yum vs ChipotleAnalyst Color Price Target Reiteration Analyst Ratings Movers Best of Benzinga


Related Articles (CMG + YUM)

View Comments and Join the Discussion!